Skip to main content

tv   The Lead With Jake Tapper  CNN  May 13, 2024 1:00pm-2:00pm PDT

1:00 pm
continue to follow new developments in former president trump's hush money trial. >> one of the biggest takeaways today, i was involving michael cohen's testimony the biggest takeaway, the $130,000 payment to stormy daniels, he says was specifically about protecting trump politically. cohen described how trump was only worried about his 2016 presidential campaign not as wife melania, when he learned the stormy daniels was trying to sell her story about an alleged affair with trump cohen told the jury he was doing everything he could to protect trump. he also testified about are each about how he tried to delay the hush money payment until after the presidential election. he recounted his conversation with trump about ultimately paying stormy daniels cohen testified them quoting, now, there's no reason to keep this thing out. there. so do it. he expressed to be just do it, meet up with allen weisselberg and figure this whole thing out. thanks very much for joining us. i'm wolf
1:01 pm
blitzer in washington. i'll be back in two hours, 6:00 p.m. eastern in the situation room. starts right now cnn's breaking news. >> and welcome to the lead. i'm jake tapper and we continue to follow the breaking news out of manhattan and where the man at the center of the hush money payments scandal is testifying right now in donald trump's criminal trial, michael cohen is detailing exactly how he came to pay $130,000 to adult film star in director stormy daniels, who came forward about an alleged episode with donald trump in the days before the 2016 election cohen testified, not only did trump know about the uh, hundred $30,000 payment, but trump directly approved it and said that he would pay cohen back and the prosecution is using cohen's testimony to present both an offensive and
1:02 pm
defensive case offensively by establishing the cohen was the man behind the payments, not just to stormy daniel's, but also to 1998 playmate of the year, karen mcdougal and defensively by trying to establish that cohen frequently lie on behalf of donald trump, getting that out there ahead of time before the defense has their say and by trying to corroborate nearly everything they can that cohen says with actual factual evidence, text messages, emails, phone records let's get straight to cnn's paula reid. paula what have been your biggest takeaways from michael cohen's testimony? 20 so far i'll take this highly anticipated appearance by michael cohen on the stand has paid dividends for prosecutors so far. >> he told the jury that at long before trump announced his candidacy for the white house, he was worried about stories from women and how they could come out and potentially impact his candidacy. cohen testified that trump told him, quote, you know, that when this comes out, meeting the announcement about
1:03 pm
his run for the white house, just be prepared. there's going to be a lot of women coming forward. >> cohen then testified to how involved he was and suppressing negative stories about trump in the lead up to the election. and that in the wake of the access hollywood tape, how he personally similarly facilitated that payment to stormy daniels. but what was new what we haven't already heard so far in this trial is how involved trump was. he testified that he he constantly kept trump updated on this ever to pay stormy daniels this hush money testified that he needed trump's approval, is certainly wanted credit for getting the story suppress, but he described trump as a micro-manager, testified to how in the loop he was now we also testified that trump promised he would get reimbursed. he said allen weisselberg, the former cfo of the trump organization, and i spoke to mr. trump. we expressed to him that i was going to front the money for the hush money to which he was appreciative. any stated to me, don't worry, you'll get the money back now in the timeline the testimony
1:04 pm
we are in late 2016 right now, cohen is expected to wrap up the next half hour or so. so we haven't quite gotten to 2017, which is of course when these dots i'm convinced at the heart of this case were allegedly falsified apollo, what do we know about the defense strategy for cross-examining cohen? >> obviously, a lot of us are backing it to be rather brutal yeah, it totally fair. >> it will be brutal. michael cohen knows it's gonna be brutal and cross-examination of michael cohen is the trump defense, which is why todd blanche, the lead attorney here. he hasn't been doing very many of the cross-examinations of witnesses. he has been exclusively focused on this cross-examination. we can expect that this will go as long if not longer than the direct examination and it will be a multimedia presentation. many of the things cohen has said about trump can we'll be used against him, really jake, the greatest challenge for prosecutors or excuse me, for defense attorneys is just calling down all of the
1:05 pm
statements, all of the attacks that cohen has launched against the defendant in the past several years. really, most of his identity is attacking trump's defense attorneys are going to seize on that and try to paint him as a liar. sure. who was out for revenge, which is of course the name of one of his books. >> all right paula reid, thanks so much. let's bring in our panel we have with us victoria nurse who served his chief counsel for then vice president joe biden former trump payroll corporation attorney bill brennan, former federal prosecutor, gene rossi, and cnn's jamie gan, gail, right now, just to give you an update on what's going on inside the courtroom right now. michael cohen is testifying about the reimbursement of $130,000 and he's talking similarly about the calculations. the back of the envelope as it were calculations by allen weisselberg, the chief financial officer of the trump organization. i think we have a copy of that document that we can show you that they're referring to. it's it's $130,000 plus additional
1:06 pm
funding that went into what cohen was paid. and and just to just to get you up to speed, one of the things that's been going on is it michael cohen is talking about how a day or two before trump left for the inauguration in january 2017 trump officially made michael cohen his personal council. he found out that his it's bonus, which usually was included in the christmas card, the check for the bonus was he was angry beyond angry because trump has slashed is bonus by two-thirds. trump laughs to himself in the courtroom when this happens and nodded, as cohen testified, he was beyond angry. he said i was truly insulted personally hurt by it, didn't understand. he said he immediately went to weisselberg's office and in some colorful language expressed to him how truly off and angry i really was. i use quite a few expletives. i was even for myself unusually angry. so one of the ideas here
1:07 pm
that they're trying to establish is this anger that michael cohen had and they're trying to get it out on their terms. the prosecution because obviously anything negative that there is about michael cohen, the defense is going to introduce evidence that the feeling obviously better that the prosecution get it out there first, let me start with you, victoria, if i could, because the stormy daniels payment right before he went to the bank to make the stormy daniels payment, cohen says he had to phone calls with trump cohen says he would never have made the payment without trump's approval. and that quote, everything required. mr. trump's sign on top of that i wanted the money back that seems like a point that the jurors can relate to wanting to be paid back uh-huh. yeah. i'm gonna think cohen has been doing a good job of explaining that this was all about the election that this is not just we call it hush money and all that tawdry stuff that my republican mother rest your
1:08 pm
pieces rolling over we're in her grave about this is really about the 2016 election and what they're doing it step-by-step, showing through the admission of the documents and all this boring stuff about who said what when that trump was there. >> trump ordered this and cohen wanted to be repaid so let's bring up that weisselberg note that i referred to earlier, which has been introduced into evidence, and it's allen weisselberg, the cfo paying back michael cohen and figuring out how much should be paid back if they grow up the number. >> so that after he pays the taxes on this check cohen would get back the full amount of money. he owed if they gave me the hundred 80,000 and they didn't grow sit up after taxes onto it. it would be $90,000. cohen says, but i suspect that you have a different take on how credible mr. cohen is seeming. >> i do. jake is surprisingly enough i mean this guy is a polluted source. he could be the dictionary photograph for polluted source. he's a
1:09 pm
narcissistic sycophant that put his star on trump's wagon. and when he didn't get what he wanted, which was a dc job, he turned on him and now he's got an extra grind and jake, those jurors don't leave their common sense of the door. what they see a witness like hope hicks will apparently has no ax to grind they take her testimony, has the ring of truth. this guy wrote a book called revenge. this guy, michael collins about michael cohen. he said earlier, i think in today's testimony from what we saw on the screen, he was hoping to monetize his role as the president's attorney i mean, i think blanche will have him on the stand for days and collins got an allergy to veracity. so it's going to be an interesting cross. >> one of the things that they're trying to establish here is that the money was actually he was paid in excess of $130,000 because it gets getting into the weeds a little bit but if they they did it as an untaxed expense reimbursement, then he would it
1:10 pm
would be less money than if he took it as income because reimbursements were not grossed up any in any case, they've already lost me, but that's why that's why i have an accountant. this all comes after cohen failed to pay stormy daniels by in the first agreed upon deadline? yeah. >> and what it looked like stormy daniel's might take her story somewhere else. cohen says, trump told him, quote he stated to me that he had spoken to some friends, some individuals, smart people, and that it's $130,000. your a billionaire, just pay it. there's no reason to keep this thing out there. so do it. that's what people said to trump as trump to michael cohen he expressed to me just do it, meet up with allen weisselberg and figure this whole thing out, right? does that have the ring of truth to you? does that sound right? >> well, here's the thing. i want to go to what bill said. there's an incident in early december, i think teeth davidson talked about it. i represented davidson and michael cohen was so mad, believe it or not, bill michael cohen thought he could be
1:11 pm
attorney general the united states. now, we all laugh at that. but trump told them he's not going to be attorney general and told them he's not even go into the white house. so an early december, this angers building and you get to crescendo with the bonus, but to go to the invoices, i call them the souffle invoices. they go from 132420 i think that if the prosecutors explain this rationally and we common sense because i did a lot of tax cases and cohen does reasonably well. i think they're going to get over that hurdle of connecting the invoices to the election interference. if they do it properly, if they screw up and fohlin, her face, donald trump's going to have a hung jury and acquittal. it's as simple as that. >> so when he first learned that stormy daniels is looking to sell her story jamie again go michael cohen testifies that he went to donald trump immediately. cohen says trump told them to handle the story and the trump said, quote, i want you to just push it out as long as you can just get past the election. because if i win
1:12 pm
it, i will have no rela it will have no relevance because i'm president and if i lose, i don't even care. so this would undermine in any claim that donald trump did this because he was worried about what might happen to melania. >> i think testimony like that goes to guilty, guilty, guilty. i mean, it really just lays it out. otherwise, you wouldn't you know, why did they were they waiting out until why did he want to wait until after the election? that is not about melania or his family being upset. it's about the election. can i just address my friend bill here, who who he gets in trouble on social media for some of our conversations which he doesn't deserve we talked before we came on. you talked about michael cohen and his personality and veracity he and donald trump work together for ten years. i would say in a certain it's fair to say they were a match made in heaven for
1:13 pm
those ten years michael cohen conducted himself the way donald trump conducted himself. and i think jurors, you're the lawyer, jill, tell me they look at who's on the stand? their reaction goes beyond the evidence and the testimony there's common sense that goes into this and i think michael cohen has, by all accounts, his tone has been even he has said he was ashamed. he has apologize. i'm not saying it gets you all the way there. but i think it helps me. >> i agree with you on i know. >> thank but but here's a cycle of the last six or seven years with cohen. he lied to congress. he lied to the irs. he went to prison he came back. he said, i'm am redeemed. i've seen the light. >> and then he had more allies and now he's redeeming.
1:14 pm
>> this guys have more comebacks and ike turner, as he testifies from that stand today, he is shopping a reality show called the fixer that anybody little pick it up. this guy always has skin in the game it makes him a polaroid. >> we're going to squeeze in a quick break. i'm going to come back. i'm gonna come back to you. you get first first shot at it out of the gate. stay with me, michael cohen right now detailing how he made the payment to stormy daniels testifying that he took out a home equity loan. he tried to hide it from his own wife. did he act under trump's orders or on his own as a faithful servant? hi, attorneys are here and they're debating what's at the heart of the case. we're going to squeeze in a quick break. we'll be right back this is a secret secrets and spies premier sunday, june 2, attempt bomb cnn water would help us. it's dry spots. that's loan disease. but scots healthy plus will cure lung disease going around. so like other people have it and it's recover bag and the newscaster
1:15 pm
field are healthy plus lawn through today no way why would i use kayak to compare hundreds of travel sites at once i like to do things myself i do my own searching you sky it i can trust anything else to do the job right hi act search one and done your idp disrupts the idp derails. >> let's be honest sucks but living to see idp doesn't have to. >> when you sign up at shining through cid p.com, you'll find inspiration and real patients stories helpful tips, reliable information, and more cid p can be tough. >> but finding hope just got a little easier. >> sign up. it's through cip.com.
1:16 pm
>> be heard, be helpful. be you posted. >> show late night. >> that sounds awesome the same to be real i think he would a full thing the daily show tonight and 11, company central time to press rewind with neutrogena rapid wrinkle repair. it has durham proven retinol expertly formulated to target stem cell turnover and fight not one, but five signs of aging. physical results in just one week neutrogena here's you're getting better with age here's the beat least to every thursday helped fuel today with boost type protein. >> complete nutrition, you need without the stuff you don't so here's two now if you have graves disease your eyes symptoms could mean something more. >> gritty feeling can be brushed away even a little blurry vision can distort things and something serious,
1:17 pm
maybe behind those itchy eyes up to 50% of people with graves could develop a different condition called thyroid eye disease which should be treated by a different doctor see an expert, find a ted is specialist at is-it ted.com? i have type two diabetes, but i'm it well it's little pill with the big story to tell. i take once-daily jati jordan's works 24/7 in your body to flush out? >> and sugar and four adults with type two diabetes, and known heart disease, jordanians can lower the risk of cardiovascular death serious side effects may include ketoacidosis that may be fatal, dehydration that can lead to several worsening of kidney function and genital yeast or urinary tract infections are rare, life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. >> stuff giardia and some call your doctor right away. way if you have symptoms of this
1:18 pm
infection, ketoacidosis, or an allergic reaction, you may have increased risk for lower limb loss. call your doctor right away. if you have symptoms of infection in your legs or feet, taking jordan's for this, we'll find your rio or insulin may cause low blood sugar rallies close captioning brought to you by meso book.com if you or a loved one have mesothelial, will send you a free book to answer questions you may have call now and we'll come to you 808 to one 4,000 we're back with our breaking news coverage. michael cohen is testifying in donald trump's hush money cover-up trial in new york right now, cohen is discussing how he was allegedly reimbursed for the $130,000 he paid stormy daniel's in the days, right before the 2016 election, my panels back with me so one of the things going on right now they have this intense examination, direct examination, not the difficult cross, but cohen, when asked about the accounting being
1:19 pm
used, that i didn't really think about it. i just wanted to get my money back at the time, cohen says he thought he would get the $420,000 back in one lump sum. this 420,000, if you're wondering how 130,000 became 420, i think this is what it is. okay. you start up with the $130,000 that they pay stormy daniels and there's some group called red finch consulting that michael cohen hired to rig online polls at donald trump's the has again, nothing legal about that either. so that's one 30 plus 50. that's $180,000. then if they just give that money to michael cohen, he would have to basically pay taxes on tens of thousands of dollars of it. so they doubled it. so he gets back in net. if you remove the taxes, what he originally spent and then an additional 60 let's you have to three at and then additional thousand dollars because allen weisselberg felt bad that michael cohen got stiff that of a decent christmas bonus. okay. i think i finally understood that during the conversation
1:20 pm
because it cohen thought he was going to get it back into $420,000 back one lump sum, allen weisselberg turns around and says, while we're talking about this, we're going to pay you over 12 months as like a legal service rendered since i was going to be given the title of personal attorney to the president, cohen recalled the prosecuting attorney, susan hoffinger says did weisselberg then show you this document? we can help put that document up again because now it's relevant again, calculating the payment there it is the payment and he says, yes he approved it. this is going to be one heck of a ride in dc. cohen recalled trump saying, well, what's, what's the purpose of all this, of all this testimony? >> well, the idea is to get to some sense that where the documents and his testimony match so that the jury sees that it's all consistent. otherwise, they're going to ask questions in the jury room about why is it not just what you did? bravo and the math why was it such a large payment by though if first time i've ever been bravo for math and my life, i'm a professor, so i would not somewhere dispatcher
1:21 pm
is very happy sorry. sorry my sister levs, if she would hayden anyway, they're trying to make this consistent because that's what you do and a criminal charge they are playing it by the book. >> they put in the documents. now they're hearing the testimony and they all have to match otherwise, juries invent reasons why hi, there may be a doubt and one reasonable doubt, one juror can scuttle the case. >> so and the defense argument here, they'll brandon is that this money was actually for legal services rendered and michael cohen is saying, no, no, no, this is happened. your says, well, what was it actually? and he says reimbursement of my money. now i get that. you don't think he's a credible witness, and i'm i'm not going to push back on that. yeah. that's certainly your opinion? does this document by allen weisselberg not buttress what he's saying happened. >> jake, even just assuming
1:22 pm
argue that it does. okay. >> who cares red finch, not illegal hush money, not illegal. they have to tie it into another crime to make the felony and that's where if the last four weeks led to michael cohen tying it all together and they don't have weisselberg to corroborated or somebody to corroborate it. i can't imagine there's not at least one juror that gets back there and scratches her head and said, this guy convicted perjure lies about everything like that was wife about the home equity loan. he's going rogue. i can't believe somebody doesn't have reasonable or go ahead. go. he said monsters are not convicted based on, you know, nice little old ladies testimony. >> they are convicted based on some unsavory characters. and this is a political monster cohen said he did this because women would be upset with what well let me let me put this this is about the stormy daniels story. let me just put up the quote so people know what you're referring to.
1:23 pm
victoria, women are going to hate me guys may think it's cool, but this is going to be a disaster for the campaign. this is the disaster, a total disaster this is about when they find out that the stormy daniels story is out there in might break especially right after the access hollywood story was out there so that's according to michael cohen, that is donald trump expressing concern about the stormy daniels story getting out there, which it did not get out there until years after the 2016 election. everyone stick around. we have a bit of drama in these final 15 minutes a day, 16 of the hush money trial, we expect core to wrap soon donald trump will almost certainly if past is prologue come out and give us his take on what he heard on the witness stand today. we're gonna be watching we're gonna be right back the whole myth has to be re-imagined yellen's feed if you didn't know whether you were next, they were both tied
1:24 pm
up yeah. yeah. i was called in and i saw what turned out to be the biggest heist in history he went from gold medal winning not to a pariah would really happened with jesse l. >> martin. sunday's at nine on cnn time. >> do press rewind with neutrogena rapid rigueur, repair. it has during the met null explicitly formulated to target and cell turnover and fight not one, but five signs of aging, physical results in just one week, neutrogena water would help us is dry spots. >> that's long disease, but scott, healthy plus with curates lung disease going around. >> so like other people have it and it's not pick up a bag of the newscaster field are healthy plus lawn through today welcome to stormy heights, where the windows are always pellet. pellet fiberglass is the strongest material for windows and patio doors. the fiberglass frame is even scratch and dent resistant. hello, windows tested for
1:25 pm
extremes, designed for your home you know, priceline most families they've 60% on family-friendly hotels. so many great trips we might just leave here with another vacation baby i'll take it easy. >> paris and youtube for motor down, lisa wasn't alito gueriniere happy priceline with armor all a little bit of this protects you from a lot of that armor all less work, more clean by $20, get five back through may 31st, name of phi, it's kind of amazing. wow, my go-to is lima phi eye drops, luma phi dramatically reduces redness in one minute and look at the difference my eyes look brighter and wider for up to eight hours. limma five really works see for yourself arthritis, pain. >> we say not today tylenol, eight hour or brightest pain has two layers are really the first is past, the second is long-lasting dame, we give you your day back so you can give it everything. tylenol number
1:26 pm
one, doctor recommended for arthritis pain fashion moves fast, setting trends is our business. >> we need to scale with customer demand in real time so we partner with verizon, their solution for us, a private by gi network. >> we now get more control of production efficiencies and greater agility with a custom private 5g networks our customers get what they want when they want it now, or even smarter and ready for what's next achieve enterprise intelligence. >> it's your vision, it's your verizon allergies with allegro. >> they won't stop me nothing beats allegro. >> it's the fastest non drowsy 24 hour allergy relief live. >> your greatness one reading seven, zero. yeah, that's not good happened huge things happen happens
1:27 pm
and they're all coming? those who are still with us, yes. grandpa! what's this? your wings. light 'em up! gentlemen, it's a beautiful... ...day to fly.
1:28 pm
powering progress i'm elizabeth wagmeister in los angeles and this is cnn and we're back with our breaking news. michael cohen is still testifying right now on the stand in donald trump's hush money cover up trial after testimony wraps today, we are expecting mr. trump so come out of the courtroom and speak. let's go to cnn's kristen holmes, who's outside the courthouse and kristin trump had a couple of allies show up for him today in korda. tell us who they are and what's his mindset when it comes to the he's guest list yeah. >> jagan coming to court with donald trump has become the new loyalty task. many of these people actually are wanting to be at the top of the ticket the long donald trump, here's what we saw today without eric tribe, alina habba, who was one of his lawyers, but not in this case, a representative from new york, nicole maluo taka's we saw the air alabama senator ami toupper, iwill. we saw jd vance out of ohio, senator there he is rumored to be on the shortlist for vice president, as well as attorney general of
1:29 pm
iowa, breonna bird, who paid pivotal role in his landslide victory in the primary and are the caucuses in that state. >> his mindset around having these visitors is that he wants the support. >> we are told by people close to the former president that he was really upset that more people were not coming out to show their support for him. and also that there weren't more protests protesters on his behalf in this courtyard across from the court house. remember they have a special little area because siphoned off for these trump protesters. there's only been about a handful someday is one or two today we saw up to five of the sorry and flag, but not the kind of resounding support that he'd like to see out here, which is of course led to him continually saying they're not allowed close to the courthouse, even though we are doing directly across the street from the courthouse. so that led to his team creating a kind of situation within new york where he would go to locations, campaign events, in areas that because likely to get a very welcome crowd, including construction sayyed, meant with a bunch of union workers as well as laborers there. he went to a harlem bodega places he would get a
quote
1:30 pm
good reception. that was in part a reaction to donald trump being upset about the lack of support here at the courthouse, look out for baur, big names, people who are trying trying to get attention from the former president showing up in court tomorrow. we are told that vivek ramaswamy will be sitting in court with donald trump all right. >> kristen holmes, thanks so much. the panels back with me. we should note that the courtroom has adjourned for the day. judge merchan saying, have a good night. see you tomorrow. cohen got up pan the courtroom, looked down in his hands for a moment when the merchan gave the judge i'm sorry, give the jury the usual previous missile instructions cohen then gave us small smile. hello, and nod over at the jury box, just as judge merchan dismissed them for the day eric trump was in court today and up here comes trump. let's let's listen into the defendant as he discusses today's events. let's see if he adheres to the the gag order to not go after
1:31 pm
witnesses. >> they view this is a scam i think it's a terrible thing that's happening to democracy in this we have a lot of under want to come. i say just stay back past lots of laws to stop things like this jd beds. what's going on? and then courtroom is a threat to democracy and we could not have a country where we get to prosecute your political opponent instead of persuading voters ag murdered as you know, having respected from iowa, let the american people decide who the next leader of the free world who will be politics is absolutely no place in this courtroom. this is all politics and in mccarthy great legal analysts said none of this is illegal. there's nothing illegal it's called politics. there's nothing illegal a lot of people said that they're all saying that the older were the only person wants ages. the
1:32 pm
judge because it's a rig deal, is conflicted. you want to check that out? >> but everybody is saying is no crime leo dirac up until right now these, there's not a single spread get evidence of president trump participated internet crime of either falsifying records you are hiding a campaign or state or federal finance yardage none of it has been absolutely nothing. >> look, enjoy a great way to doing great. they kept me here for three-and-a-half, four weeks instead of campaigning yet you still have the best whole numbers just came out in the new york times as we discussed before mock live in libya this as safely as possible oh, there's no ghraieb state or federal with which delayed donald trump or anyone else. this is a case looking for a legal basis. there is none. there is no crime. >> it's mark levin again, jd vance do the american voters,
1:33 pm
who are watching this? one opportunity you get to speak up against his sham prosecution and just say the american people should elect the president not use corrupt d&c prosecutors two help them get elected, which is exactly what they view in any regard the good break has no authority to enforce federal law. >> the nda payments were you're paying expenditures under federal law that's why the epc and doj, which do have exclusive authority to enforce federal law absolutely no action against trump. they took no action against me. they look they said it's time the only went and did the shores back da brad coe turned down the case by the way he turned down the case and it couldn't have been brought six years ago, seven years ago, almost eight years ago. >> they bring it right in the middle of my presidential campaign break. >> he said we had a case, you know, if you go back take a look at your earlier records when he came into office, he
1:34 pm
turned it down and he was angry because of what took place when he saw that they were going to use this scam. he was angry even my pill smerconish have cnn a person four for five weeks into a trial or be told exactly that, which they're being prosecuted for that hasn't happened. you know what happened one very simple reason, because the is no crime, his bark decent. i don't think so. i don't think things, you know, i'm very well for the prosecution in the court of law. and the court of public opinion, they're doing even worse matt whitaker, another day of trial and then keeping the president of the campaign trail byron you on the hush money trial, which is not money. majority of voters pennsylvania, michigan save trump cannot get a fair trial. that's too bad. that's really
1:35 pm
true any regard to break exactly what he's doing. >> it's improper, completely political case maybe merge john judge versha is having second thoughts. i haven't come to us improving. it had not come close to approving fraud or that any fraud has taken place there's no fraud here there's no prime here. >> this is for weeks and keeping me from not campaigning. >> jonathan turley can imagine any competent order would not be embarrassed what is happened in this courtroom this day is truly going to go down information for the new york legal system, which is true the whole world well now, new york weaponized legal system watching this unfold, that courtroom as a lawyer is really deeply disturbing. he was referring to these documents and documents don't move the block the document shows that
1:36 pm
the nda and the payment that is not in the spirit there. this is a total this is jonathan generally they're not unlawful energy federal campaign contribution. >> there's absolutely no problem. >> there's no problem with, you know, the mtc itself mpc the elections commission, federal elections commission, they lifted this years ago and they took a fast. they said there's no problem here tim scott objective is to keep dropped off the campaign trail as all they tried to do, keep him off the campaign trail. here's the new york times. it just came out with so while ago where we're leaving in every state and every the five q stakes relieving very substantially. i might add. >> so it's all believers said day for the country and said from new york, i mean new york, that a judge is highly conflicted at a level that
1:37 pm
nobody has seen before for can possibly think of it. and you should go out and check it out but we have a corrupt and we have a judge is highly i can and he's keeping me from campaigning. hizon appointed new york judge, appointed you know appointed him but read politicians he's appointed is a corrupt judge and is conflicted. the judge and he only let us go out and campaign and get rid of this every single legal atlas even cnn even msdnc, the same there's no case here thank you very much kind of dealing with all right, or rather angry defendant saying there's no case here. and for the record, although we certainly have people such as mr. brennan on our panel here who are arguing that this is
1:38 pm
not a strong case. it's certainly not the view of them. cnn person per say that there is no case here. we are discussing the qualities of the case. so the good, the bad, there's disagreement. we do have people who are in mr. trump's sayyed on this oh, lovable will will will on whether an on mobile and on the issue on the issue of whether or not this is a good case. that's all i'm when i look at this. >> yeah, they're might as well be one of those things when they used to put the blue around the face. this is an american citizen on trial. yeah and they have to tie it up to another crime and they've yet to do it. >> this has nothing to do with the fact that i represented him no trump. i have no political agenda about your view of the quality of this guy. i think they haven't made it out yet. that's all i'm saying all right. okay. >> anyway, but jamie, again, go very angry and he he he he seemed angry are today than in any previous de guesses his day 16, he seemed angry are today
1:39 pm
with michael cohen's testimony, than he did on either of the days were stormy daniels was testifying and at least one of those days she said some things that were rather embarrassing and even some people who are in favor of this case thought that the prosecution and the witness went too far, but he seemed angrier than ever today. >> so what do psychiatrists call it? is it transference that he's, you know, he's not allowed to say anything about that. michael cohen. he hasn't broken the gag order. >> oh, yeah. right. that's good on the other hand, he was yelling about the judge. >> he's allowed to yell about the judge. and so he went there. i just one other issue we should note this, judge is widely respected judge juan merchan is one of the most well-respected judges at 100 centre street. >> but they're all right. >> yeah. yeah, there are under are those who say that that he should have recused himself because his daughter does work for democratic consulting group of sorts. i'm not saying he should have, but i mean that is when he says he's conflicted,
1:40 pm
he's not the only one that thing junior wanted to say. i just want to say this when you see a defendant like mr. trump rant and rave and just stipulate and go off at tangents. >> my mind was going to explode. what that tells me is that he sat through several hours of testimony and it hit home it hit home. >> well, this guy was his fixer, donald trump for all his faults. >> he knows that michael cohen in my view, was connecting with the jury. now, i wasn't into jury, but that's a guy who knows at what michael cohen said was accepted, or at least listened to by the jury. that's what i see from that high had defendants that reacted like this. and here's what here's what mr. trump cannot do during his trial. the rest of your trial? he has to keep a poker face which will be impossible because that jury is watching his reaction to everything that michael cohen is saying if michael cohen says
1:41 pm
something and mr. trump is reacting angrily, the jury is going to say it must be true but we don't know that they're seeing that. we don't know that the jury is seeing the well, we don't know. we don't i mean, they might just be seeing him with a stone face. we have no idea from what i don't think he has a stone face. >> okay. but i just respond to the legal argument. >> he's making here. i could get 100 law professors in here to say that falsifying crimes is a basic crime. phosphite documents under new york state law. this is the defense of someone i agree who knows that the testimony has hit home because he's taking a legal argument, he's making a legal argument. and is not exactly what i would expect if someone who was innocent. >> all right, thanks. one and all appreciated. or retired judge who has been watching this case closely joined wednesday next, her take on the prosecution's case so far with the defense needs to do how high-profile witnesses such as michael cohen can theoretically change the dynamics of a courtroom that's all next, stay with us smart minor is all
1:42 pm
about protecting your vehicle from the inside out with quality and durability we use innovative 3d scanning to create top of the line custom bit more liners make this smart choice, choose smart liner. honestly, i was scared when i was told age-related macular degeneration could jeopardize my vision. >> great. >> one more thing to worry about. >> it was all too hard to deal with in the beginning, but making a plan with my doctor to add preservation was easy. >> preservation. a red tube contains the exact any i recommended clinically proven nutrient formula to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. >> thanks, suppressor vision. i feel better that i'm doing something about it, like millions of others preservation everywhere. but the seat it is 11 allen beginning. you love your bike. we do too. that's why we're american. number one motorcycle insurer. what do you have to wedge it and everything? will do that surmise me i'd like the wolf
1:43 pm
was about the size of my new motorcycle. >> have you seen it by the way? >> but i ground look how brushstrokes bottled a line of a gas tanker problem of plus one jamie ga. >> the advanced form of dry age-related macular degeneration can irreversibly damaged your vision. it can progress faster than you think ga threatens your eyes. take a stand slow ga with saif ovary saif ovary is an eye injection that was proven to slow damaging legion growth over two years with increasing effect it's over time it's the only fda approved treatment to slow ga and his view is six doses per year don't take psi fovea. >> if you have an infection section or active swelling in or around your eye that may include pain and redness safe over you can cause serious side effects such as eye infection
1:44 pm
and retinal detachments severe inflammation of vessels in the retina, which may result in severe vision loss. wet amd, ai inflammation, and an increase in high-pressure most common side effects or eye discomfort, wet amd small specks floating envision, and blood in the white of the eye. tell your doctor right away, if you have any side effects every moment counts act now to slow ga, with siphon ovary ask your retina specialist about safe ovary were you worried the wedding would be too much now other destination. >> why do we just got hi for versus just nap book? it's married and nap up my daughter who gets made some, please, more expensive my daughter jamaica why can't they use fight back within power? >> we get all our financial questions answered, so we didn't have to worry can we get out of here? >> i thought you'd never ask. >> join 18 million americans and take control of your financial future with a real-time dashboard in real life conversations empower what's next.
1:45 pm
>> today. >> at america's beverage companies are models might still look the same, but they can be remade in a whole new way. >> thanks to you. we're getting bottles back and we've developed a way to make new ones from 100% recycled plastic new bottles made using no new plastic. >> you'll be seeing more of these bottles in more places. >> and when we get more of them back we can use less new plastic bottles are made to be remade here, you can expect to find crystal clear audio expensive display space more comfort for everyone but we still left room for all the unexpected things. >> you'll find out here. the new 2020 it four grand cherokee lined up jeep, there's only one. >> it's cheap, four by four season. we're right now get the 2024 jeep grand cherokee starting at $38,290 msrp visit cheap.com for details how
1:46 pm
solomon in new york is cnn and we're back with more of our continuing coverage of donald trump's hush money cover up conspiracy trial with me now to give, uh, judge's perspective of the cases, retired california superior court judge ladoris hazard cordell also the author of the book, her honore. judge cordell, thanks for joining us. this was one of the biggest days of the trial so far. certainly the one that seemed to make mr. trump the angry, just what does it feel like as a judge when you see a big witness on upon whom the entire case might hinge take the stand. what does that like as a judge? >> well, thank you for inviting me on jake first, i have to tell you, i chuckle when i hear various pundits weighing in about how various witnesses like michael cohen are likely to be perceived by the jurors and i presided over many criminal jury trials, some of them high-profile, and i stopped trying to second-guessed jurors. it. you just just can't do it so
1:47 pm
michael cohen testified today and this is one half of the case, meaning it's the prosecution sayyed, we don't know how he will hold up in cross-examination. my guess is that he will be well he's no dummy he knows the questions that are likely to be asked to pim. and that's why the prosecution went to some extent, maybe they should have done a little bit more talking about the bad stuff about michael cohen that he was the fixer and he considered himself in trump's thug, those kinds of things. so that it won't hit the jurors brand new. one and they defense steps up. but so far, you we haven't used mustn't lose sight of and particularly as a judge, presiding, i'd hear all these various witnesses. you can't lose sight of why people are there in the courtroom and they're there in a courtroom because a crime or crimes are
1:48 pm
being being alleged. >> and in this so if they've established and they will that documents were falsified, i think they will do that. >> then the issue is and part of the crime is did trump with knowledge is falsified documents. do it with the intent to commit amid another crime or to aid or conceal the commission of the crime. and so that's the issue here. the intent and how do you prove intent, jake, you can't unless you get inside somebody's head at the time. so we can't do it that way, then it's proved by circumstantial evidence. and in a trial or circumstantial evidence is given the same weight as direct evidence. so that's really what this case is about. and michael cohen now is kinda pulling all the pieces together. so it's a fascinating story. it's very sad that these kinds of things were going on we've only heard part of it. the other part is going to come from the
1:49 pm
cross-examination of mr. cohen and whether or not any defense is put on at all michael cohen might be the last prosecution witness. >> do you think it's smart to end the case and the presentation of a case on the testimony of somebody who does have a record, a convicted record of being lot of lying and perjury yeah. >> i think it's fine. and the jurors, they're not naive people. and i'm sure there have been other people who have testified in courts who don't have great backgrounds. that's really in my view, that's not going and i have an impact on the jurors. i do want to add, though, that with regard to the defense, sayyed donald trump's latest rant just a few minutes ago in front of everyone, it was a rent is exactly the reason why he won't be testifying. he is a loose cannon. and another point about that rent. >> he said, and i hope people listen very carefully fully that there was no crime. >> he did not deny anything. he
1:50 pm
didn't deny the payment. he didn't deny the affair. he just said what i did was not a crime. >> so it's very, very interesting so i think it's just proved that he is definitely not going to be testifying because he can't be controlled once he starts talking as a judge, have you ever been surprised by a jury absolutely. all the time. and thank you for asking that because i've presided over trials, be they drunk driving trials or be they big felony cases. and the jurors will go off and i'm sitting there thinking there'll be they are like 20 minutes because this is a slam dunk. oh, no, no, no. >> it's really interesting what jurors gets their attention when they're in there. they also have the written jury instructions with them in their and they take their jobs very, very seriously. and sometimes to my surprise, they get hung up on some issues that i thought were non issues so i think most trial judges are surprised
1:51 pm
quite frequently about what jurors look at, what they think is important and what they don't. so i'm this case, it's very interesting. you have all these different people and that's what makes jury deliberations so interesting, right? you have all these people gather. >> they have come from different walks of life. >> and then you're gonna get all these viewpoints and at some point the, the hope is they coalesce behind a decision because of course the decision has to be unanimous what do you expect the defense to hit on beyond michael cohen's credibility? >> when they do their cross of him um, do you think that they will try to undermine some of the evidence? what do you think their focus will be again beyond credibility, which i expect will be there. they're obvious focus sure. that there are three important parts. there are only three important parts to a trial. there's documentary evidence that's audio recordings transcripts, invoices, emails, copies of checks. there's witnesses testimony, and then the other
1:52 pm
the third important part, or jury instructions. so the witness testimony is really jurors or fact fighters, so they're gathering facts, they have documents, and now they're listening to the witnesses so what the defense is going to do with michael cohen has tried to shake that testimony one, yes. credibility. but also, their position. and i think it's an unfortunate one is donald trump's position is none of this happened. nothing. he's just denying everything. >> so it's really going to be hard for them given the documentary evidence, it's already in to show that michael cohen is a liar. >> i distinct they want the jury to dislike him so much that they just don't want them to give me the time to him, in which case the case will fall apart. i mean, he is the key once they have laid down the foundation. >> all right. judge ladoris hazard, a cordell. thank you so much. appreciate your time and expertise court has adjourned for the de and donald trump's
1:53 pm
hush money conspiracy trial. michael cohen testifying on the stand today for around five hours prosecutors expected to resume direct examination tomorrow morning. cnn's kara scannell was inside the courtroom today. qarrah, how was mr. trump's demeanor when michael cohen? was on the stand donald trump for a lot of the testimony today with sitting back in the chair with his eyes closed not reacting too much. >> but there were certain moments when he did react. one was in michael cohen brought up melania trump and trump had made a face and in that context, cohen was talking about melania trump and what her reaction would have been had she learned about the stormy daniels story. just as trump was negotiating, according to michael cohen, to try to bury it. the other time was toward the end of the testimony, trump would pass notes to his lawyers when michael cohen was getting some to some of the details of the his conversations with trump about his bonus. and when michael cohen was talking about his bonus, he said that he was angry, even for myself,
1:54 pm
unusually angry about having his bonus cut by two-thirds. trump had kind of laughed to himself and smiled and reacted to that. clearly suggesting he had some kind of memory of that. but throughout, michael cohen himself was very measured even when talking about some of these conversations, he spoke slowly. he was very deliberate in the words that he chose. one is answering these questions and we did not see any kind of reaction from him. more him losing any cool while he was on the stand, jake, cnn's kaitlan collins was also in the courtroom today. >> caitlin, did the jury seem engaged oh, they were completely engaged in jake. >> they have been throughout this trial, but one thing i'll say about the story is you cannot tell how they feel about certain pieces of testimony or certain moments inside the courtroom you can't really discern anything from their faces. they're kind of expressionless during this. they are paying very close attention and they certainly
1:55 pm
wars. michael cohen was on the stand because as the jury came in after the lunch break, which is the first time that i was in the courtroom today, they picked up their notepads immediately. they had their pens in their hands. they are watching very closely and there were times when they're getting when michael cohen got in there where he was only speaking directly to the prosecutor's. he put on his glasses as he was reading text messages or emails off the screen that shows because the evidence in front of them, but he wasn't really looking at the jury, but that seemed to change later on as the testimony went on, there were moments where he would explain why he took out the home equity line of credit. he would look directly at the jurors. there was another moment where it attempted to be some kind of effort to humanize michael cohen to this jury maybe endear him to them. he was talking about his close relationship that he has with his daughter and how she was worried that he wasn't going to get a job inside the administration. and then there showing those texts he was looking directly at the jury as they were as he was telling that story, jake and the other person in the courtroom that i was watching closely is todd blanche. that's trump's leader
1:56 pm
the attorney here who was seated all the way to the right of the defense table. so he is the best view of the witness. he was watching michael cohen intently. he was often chewing on a pen and writing notes and watching him so closely because of course, todd blanche is going to be the one who cross-examined him when the prosecution has done with them. >> all right. thanks to both. you really appreciate it, caitlin, of course, we will look for more of your reporting coming up tonight on the source at 9:00 p.m. only on cnn unique perspective next hour from a criminal defense attorney who was also inside that courtroom today as michael cohen testified, and another big story in the next hour, this one in baltimore, where crews plan to demolish parts of that collapsed bridge that are still sitting on a container ship in that maryland port, that demolition is expected literally any minute. we're going to squeeze in a quick break. we'll be right back a lot of new dry eye patients in my office. >> tell me about their frequent dry eyes, which may point to dry eye disease. millions of americans were estimated to
1:57 pm
have that. they've tried artificial tears again and again. but the relief his temporal zaida can provide lasting relief. >> xi drug treats the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease, don't use if you're allergic to cetera, common side effects include ayer rotation discomfort are blurred visual, and applied to the eye and unusual taste sensation why wait, ask your doctor about a 90 day prescription resides today imagine a future where plastic is not wasted, but instead remade over and over into the things that keep our food fresher our families safer and our planet cleaner to help us get their america's plastic makers are investing billions of dollars to create innovative products and new recycling technologies for sustainable change because when you push for smarter solutions week things can happen posted late night. that sounds insane to be real i think he would a full
1:58 pm
thing. >> berkeley centrally, the daily show tonight and 11 on comedy central good looking the hotels.com to find you want perfect somewhere make your first move with battery power. >> made by steel right now, save $50 the fsa 57 battery
1:59 pm
trimmer said real still, find yours i'm tom
2:00 pm
forming in washington. >> and this is cnn this is cnn breaking news welcome to the lead. >> i'm jake tapper in this hour, today's star witness in the hush money cover of conspiracy case, michael cohen who testified that donald trump told him an alleged sexual encounter that stormy daniel's wa