there was a woman named tricia todd who had gone missing. >> deborah: tricia todd is a single mom who's recently been divorced. her 2-year-old daughter faith had been left with her regular babysitter, denise toffanello. >> couldn't get in touch with her, couldn't get in touch with her. something's not right. >> the babysitter called me or chasity, my wife, and just said, "hey, no one's come and got the child." >> i said, "i have faith. i haven't been able to get in touch with your sister." i said, "what do you want me to do? tricia's just not answering her phone." >> i knew something was wrong right there, because tricia, wherever she was, if she had to crawl to get there, she would've picked up faith. >> deborah: so that's a major red flag for you? >> oh, yeah. >> we just stopped by the babysitter's house on the way home, picked up faith, had no idea what was going on. we were just in full speculation mode of, what in the world could cause this? like, what's going on? >> and then we called the police and told them she's a missing person. >> tricia's other brother, joshua, found her car