twitter. and don't go away. "20/20" starts right now. she said, well, if anything happens to me, you know who did it. that was the night she was murdered. >> tonight on "20/20" -- the burning bed. a house with secrets to burn. >> there's no way she's going to survive this. >> the woman trapped inside had secrets, too. >> she had problems with me. >> made men angry. >> "20/20" follows the cluls of an explosive whodunit. >> she was kill ltd inside her home. >> a revolving door of men who could be suspects. her angry ex-boyfriend. or her brand new fiance, engaged after just three weeks? >> i tell you what, man, this conversation is over. >> but then, the biggest bombshell of all. >> why were you so convinced? >> because lucy told us. >> lucy, speaking from the grave, in her very own journal.

>> i mean, she wrote it down. >> for the first time tonight, the jury, the verdict, the outrage with the police on trial, too. >> who dropped the ball? >> who killed lucy johnson, in the burning bed? here now, elizabeth vargas and david muir. good evening. elizabeth has the evening off. as we come on the air, a question. is a killer still walking the streets of the small american town, because tonight, authorities say where there's smoke, there's fire. and not just a house on fire, but a burning bed. tonight here who was in that bed and was the kill earl one of them? you're about to get an inside look at the evidence. you decide. here's jim avila. >> reporter: 3:00 in the morning down hidden meadow court. a warm, sticky night, clear skies, full moon, the peaceful scene shattered by a spark. >> gaston county 911. >> we have a house fire, fully

engulfed, 4835 hidden meadow court. >> you think there's somebody inside? >> reporter: suddenly the sky lights up bright. a house is burning, and it looks bad. neighbors are horrified. >> we think there is somebody inside, please help us. there's a lady's car here, she's not answering -- there's no way she's going to survive this. >> and now at noon, a house burned down to the ground where a mother and two children lived. eyewitness news reporter ken lemon, he's been on the scene all morning. >> reporter: reporter ken lemon is among the first on the scene. >> as you mentioned, police can't stay it was that woman. the house was in ruins. and you could tell it was a pretty bad fire. >> reporter: the missing lady is 31-year-old lucy johnson. married twice. a well-liked young mother living with her two children, working as an emergency room nurse. lucy's children are safe. they had spent the night with their respective fathers.

but where is lucy? >> and then i hear from more neighbors who say, you know, "i was at the back door. i was at the door trying to get in and i couldn't get inside." and they began to tell me about the woman they couldn't account for. >> reporter: this grim document obtained from the investigation file has the terrible answer. it shows a badly burned body in an upstairs bedroom. >> as you know, we do have a body in the house and it is deceased. >> reporter: that body, unrecognizable, identified only by dental x-rays and the serial numbers on her breast implants. and sadly, yes, it is lucy. a police officer calls her father, mike dye. >> she informed me that there was a fire at lucy's house, and i asked her, i said, "well, did lucy get out?" she said, "no, lucy is still in the house." so, i broke down. >> reporter: with a body inside, this is more than a fire. police are called, arson

inspectors. it's an all out investigation. in the ashes, those investigators immediately notice something strange -- the burn patterns. a trained fire dog detects a suspicious trail of burnt gasoline leading from lucy's bed, down the blackened stairway and out the back door. >> it wasn't an accident. >> reporter: no, this is arson. >> and then suddenly this car comes racing right up to the police tape. and this guy jumps out and he runs into the arms of the first person there and he starts crying. >> reporter: it's mike mead, and he's trying because inside the smoking hulk of a building is the woman with whom he's planning a future. when you get there, what do you see? >> oh, lord. the house was still smoldering, still smoking. >> reporter: lucy was his fiance. you think to this day that she was the love of your life? >> yeah, i think she was.

>> reporter: mike mead and lucy johnson were building that future in gaston county, north carolina. once known for cotton mills and corn whiskey. west of charlotte, maybe, south of justice. where authorities now have to ask -- who would want to burn lucy's house down? friends and family say lucy was on the feisty side of southern belle, a good woman with a weakness for cigarettes, mountain dew, pick-up trucks and the men who drove them. lucy's uncle, ken dye, likes to call some of them unsuitable gentlemen. >> she had problems with men. >> reporter: bad choices? >> bad choices. >> reporter: deana bradshaw has known lucy since they were teenagers. >> she needed love. she never wanted to be by herself. and i believe that was her downfall. >> reporter: lucy likes

kids. shell has a 7-year-old daughter with her first husband and a 6-month-old infant son with a recent ex-boyfriend, a man named jim spelock, who made his living at the nearby kacatawba nuclear plant. now, lately there is little love lost between lucy and jim. broken up before their baby is even born. in fact, after the delivery, right there in the recovery room there is a nasty scene over, of all things, the newborn baby's name. >> i have never seen an individual so obsessed with the naming of a child. >> reporter: private investigator steve ehlers says spelock wants the baby named after him, james spelock iii. but headstrong lucy would have none of that and names the boy cason. that doesnt go over well with daddy. they argue and lucy kicks jim out of the maternity ward. and he doesn't go quietly. taking with him baby presents and the car seat. >> he just went into a berserk outrage. >> takes her car and leaves her

stranded at the hospital with no way home, no car seat. >> reporter: jim and lucy spend a loft time in and out of court, fighting over custody, child support and that name. >> yeah, if she wanted to get her way, she was going to get her way. that was lucy. >> reporter: she was outspoken. >> yes. she didn't take no stuff. >> reporter: but by the summer, some daylight begins to shine on lucy's life. that's when she meets, online, 39-year-old mike mead. he has a pickup, phew he also has a bmw. a successful inventor and entrepreneur from nearby fort mill, south carolina, who enjoys the finer things, like sitdown dinners at the steakhouse chain. >> she was dressed really nice. i dressed up nice and we went out to longhorn, had dinner. you know, i was real curious about why she was wanting to date somebody when she just had a baby. >> reporter: can i ask you what was special about this relationship? how you get that attached that soon? >> i just felt like we really had this connection, and we went right into family mode. the kids all got along, our

three dogs got along, i mean, it was like just everything just clicked. >> reporter: they hit it off. whirlwind relationship. and right off the bat, less than three weeks after meeting, lucy has some news for mike -- she is pregnant. >> very unexpected, very unplanned. >> reporter: you just met this woman. >> right. >> reporter: and soon after you find out she's going to have your baby? >> that's right. >> reporter: mike says he quickly got used to the idea of becoming a new dad. they were in love. mike saved this voicemail lucy left two nights before her sudden death. >> hey, baby, it's me. just calling to say good night. i'm going to bed right now. so, i love you and i'll talk to you tomorrow. bye. >> i was happy. i was tickled to death, you know. lucy was beautiful, smart, she was a fantastic mother. you know, i couldn't think of anybody i'd want to have a baby with more. >> reporter: so tickled that just three months into their love affair, he gives lucy a diamond engagement ring. a great big one. >> we felt like, you know, we're going to be together, we're going to have this baby, it's going to be wonderful, so you

know, let's just go ahead and get -- let's do it. >> reporter: a couple nights later, lucy cooks mike a pot roast with biscuits at her home in gastonia. good times, says mike. until a shadow is cast over the evening by the roar of a pickup truck outside. it's jim spelock, the ex-boyfriend, arriving for his visitation day. there to pick up his infant child for the night. >> when she came back from the door, her demeanor was all different. >> reporter: what did he want from her that night? >> well, he told her that he had filed a motion to take cason to pennsylvania for two weeks. >> reporter: evening spoiled. so mike goes home. lucy drops by her close friend deana's house to do her hair and show off that ring. >> it was a very nice ring, large diamond, princess cut, it was a ring that he had previously gave a girl before. he reused the ring and gave it to lucy.

>> reporter: hours later, the spite fire of a young nurse, in love, engaged to a man of means, carrying his child, excited that her life is finally turning around, but now, it's all over. lucy is dead. her body sprawled across her burning bed. >> they said her body was positioned in a funny way on the bed. >> reporter: you believe that looked like there was a struggle? >> yes. the way it was described. >> reporter: surprisinsurprisina victim of a fire, there is no soot, no ash in her airway. that can mean only one thing -- when the fire started, lucy wasn't breathing. she was already dead. suddenly the police clam up. they have more disturbing clues to follow. >> they still wouldn't tell us anything. they wouldn't even tell us how she died. >> reporter: when we come back, if the fire didn't kill lucy, what did? and the more unsettling question, who did?

>> that [ bleep ] killed my daughter. [ male announcer ] this is kevin. to prove to you that aleve is the better choice for him, he's agreed to give it up. that's today? [ male announcer ] we'll be with him all day as he goes back to taking tylenol. i was okay, but after lunch my knee started to hurt again. and now i've got to take more pills. ♪ yup. another pill stop. can i get my aleve back yet? ♪ for my pain, i want my aleve. ♪

[ male announcer ] look for the easy-open red arthritis cap. ♪ now they're part of our 2 for $25 guest favorites!r one olive garden dishes. get your all-time favorites like creamy chicken alfredo. plus unlimited salad and breadsticks and dessert. 2 for $25 guest favorites at olive garden. they can see the light of a single candle. look after them with centrum silver. multivitamins for your eyes, heart and brain. centrum silver. for the most amazing parts of you.

so say hello to ocean spray 100% juice. and goodbye to added sugar. i thought we weren't adding any sugar. oh. okay, nobody use these cranberries over here. milk and cereal cereal and milk milk and cereal cereal and milk k - e - double - l - o - double good protein to help you rebuild like you should great tasting grains to help you recharge

put a spring in your step so you keep livin' large milk and cereal cereal cereal add a little sunshine to your morning with delicious kellogg's® cereal and milk. it has protein to help you rebuild, and grains to help you recharge for the day ahead. shouldn't breakfast always be k-e-double-l-o-double good? ♪ show 'em the curve. it's beautiful. it's more than that... ...it's perfect. introducing curved ultra high definition television from samsung.

"20/20" continues with the burning bed. once again, jim avila. >> reporter: as lucy johnson's house on hidden meadow court smolders, gaston county, north carolina, police are feeling the pressure. a nurse and caring mother of two with another baby on the way, her badly scorched body found atop her burning bed. the police interrogation room needs a revolving door with the long list of exes, from two husbands, a former boyfriend and the fiance. to question. which way to turn? everyone is watching. including local tv reporter ken lemon. >> the thing that i think really drew people in is that you have a single mother. and she was excited about her, you know, relationship and her

engagement with this man. >> reporter: where would the evidence lead police? first, a quick search of the house, shown in this police video, seems to rule out a stranger. no evidence of a break-in here. the locks are still intact. >> she was killed in her home. that's a total violation. and the belief is that she was killed in her home by somebody she knew. not by a straunger. >> reporter: next, police move to the autopsy sketch. the medical examiner must have worn out his pen illustrating the terrible damage. and there, inside lucy's head, a find that will change the investigation -- a bullet. and then more. fragments of a second bullet. conclusion? lucy was shot twice in the back of the head. now, it's not only an arson case -- now, friends, we have a murder. the very public search for a killer is on. and local media is watching. >> so many questions today about a fire that took the life of a

pregnant mother. >> we have several people of interest that we're looking at right now. >> so everybody's watching. people wanted to know who did this. >> reporter: another clue from the crime scene -- the burned out house. lucy's engagement ring can't be found anywhere. but also missing and perhaps even more important is a murder weapon. where is the gun? >> dive crews are back at lake wylie looking for evidence to solve a pregnant mother's murder. >> reporter: they target an area near a boat landing not far from the home of a potential suspect, lucy's ex-boyfriend jim spelock. >> two days of diving for a weapon didn't produce anything. >> reporter: there's no weapon. there's no gun found. >> there's nothing. >> reporter: with no fingerprints, everything destroyed in the burned-out house, no murder weapon and no eyewitnesses to the crime, police must now turn to the circumstantial clues. starting with the men in lucy's life. lucy's uncle, ken dye, saw them come and saw them go. she made some men angry. >> she -- yes.

>> reporter: gaston county police open up the interrogation room. they bring in phillip okrulica for questioning. he's lucy's first husband and the father of her daughter lauren. when they were together, okrulica was arrested for domestic violence twice. he comes in to tell police he never really hit lucy, but he did grab her. but that trail cools when okrulica has a tight alibi. the night of the fire, he says he was home all night, and his new wife confirms it. onto lucy's husband number two, jim johnson. another relationship that got ugly at the end. he has a police record of violence against lucy, and lucy's friend deana says she witnessed one incident. >> he had her cornered in a corner, drilling her like a sergeant. barking at her verbally, loud. she was afraid. she was very afraid. >> he was a suspect because he had threatened to burn her house down. >> reporter: that's a pretty good reason to be a suspect. >> right.

>> reporter: but more investigation shows johnson was on the carolina coast, four hours away at the time of the crime, forcing police to dismiss him as a suspect. so, now we turn our attention to mike mead, lucy's new fiance and father to be. mike and lucy's romance was so recent, that day at the fire was the first time her uncle ken dye had ever seen him. >> i didn't know who he was, never met him before, didn't recognize him. and then, i noticed that the detectives put him in the car and was talking to him. >> reporter: but of all the stops on lucy johnson's troubled trail of romance, one man stood out. at least to family and friends. >> oh, yes. at the very, very beginning i thought jim spelock had did it. everyone did. >> reporter: james spelock, the father of lucy's infant son, is in the family's crosshairs. lucy's father, mike dye. >> that [ bleep ] killed my daughter.

>> reporter: ken dye says his mother, who raised lucy from when she was a teenager, was convinced the minute she heard about the fire. >> she said, "i know who done it." i said, "who done it?" he said, "jim spelock done it." >> i knew immediately he did it. something i felt in the pit of my stomach. >> reporter: why? >> lucy's moving. she's marrying somebody that's going to be able to help her financially. >> reporter: it is documented, spelock has been fighting with lucy over child support and custody. lucy has pictures of bruises on her arms and in family court claims spelock put them their while she was pregnant with their son. the relationship so poisonous, jim spelock had been recording their conversations. >> you're a very sneaky manipulative person and it ain't going to work. >> no, you're the sneaky, manipulative person, jim. >> i'm not. >> because you're the one that did all of that. you're the one that was at the lawyer's office the day after i gave birth. >> i wasn't at the office i was on the phone with them. >> you're concerned with yourself.

>> reporter: that's jim spelock documenting his attempts to see his son. >> do you plan on paying child support voluntarily? >> well, i guess that's up to you. can i see my son or not? i've seen him like five times since he's been born. are you going let me see him? >> yes and you can bring me some money when you come see him. >> reporter: police want to know where spelock was the night of the murder, but he has plausible alibi too. he tells police he was at his house all night, with the baby. >> did you stay here all night taking care of cason? >> yeah. i was here all night. >> reporter: he has a roommate who says he didn't hear jim leave. then police find and interview this woman, who was up late, texting with jim spelock most of that night. >> did he text you tuesday? >> he sent me the text at 4:30. >> just want to make sure i have it all here. >> reporter: but while the clues may be sending the family in jim spelock's direction, law enforcement is not convinced. >> and when other people began to focus their coverage towards spelock, they were able to tell

me early on, "don't go there. don't do that." >> reporter: police even issue a rare public statement clearing spelock on paper. it's unheard of. police are going in a different direction and they make an arrest. so, who do you think man in the orange jump suit is? we're live tweeting throughout tonight's show. use #abc2020. coming up here, we'll take you inside that police interrogation room. two cops and one suspect with a very strange way to show his grief. you'll see it for yourself.

♪ nothing will keep you from magnum. made with silky vanilla bean ice cream, rich caramel sauce and belgian chocolate. discover magnum chocolate pleasure. if it doesn't work fast... you're on to the next thing. neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repair has the fastest retinol formula to visibly reduce fine lines and wrinkles in just one week. neutrogena®. ♪ [ female announcer ] is your morning trying to tell you something?

maybe we should have gotten him one? [ female announcer ] sweet, creamy iced coffee from mcdonald's. another reason to love mccafé. [ female announcer ] sweet, creamy iced coffee from mcdonald's. touch down... every morning... ten times! not just... now and then. once more on the rise... nuts to the flabby guys! go, you chicken fat,

go away! go, you chicken fat, go! run, two, run (running) (like a tortoise) okay! (too far, and too slow.) now double up, ready! run two three four... (running) run two three four... (like a hare) run two three four... (now you are) run two three four... (getting there) run two three four... (go you) run two three four... (chicken fat,) everybody sing! (go away!) go, you chicken fat, go! go! go! go! dismissed! ♪ make every day, her day with a full menu of appetizers and entrées

crafted with care and designed to delight. fancy feast. love served daily. "20/20" continues. here again, jim mavila. >> breaking news out of gaston county. >> reporter: it is breaking

news. a shocking development in gaston county, north carolina's biggest murder mystery in years. >> new developments in the lucy johnson murder case. >> reporter: the man lucy johnson was in a bit earl custody battle is w is ruled out as her killer. and now in an even more surprising move, the man lucy had told everyone was the answer to her prayers, mike mead, is arrested. >> police say mike mead shot lucy johnson to death in her home last summer. >> reporter: it catches everyone offguard, especially mike mead, the successful local businessman, never before akulgzed of a violent crime. the man no one suspected of threatening lucy is now charged with arson, rape and murder. local tv reporter ken lemon was on the case from the beginning. >> when the charges came out, they seemed to come out of left field. >> reporter: prosecutors, motivated by the sympathetic, innocent victim, and the death of her unborn child, seek the death penalty. how did mike mead become the prime suspect?

police became suspicious when they first brought him in. he denied killing lucy but after this interrogation obtained by discovery channel, investigators are convinced that the whirlwind storybook romance is a sham. >> i felt so in love with her, so close to her. you know, it just hurts me thinking that you guys would even think that i -- >> well -- >> i would have no motive. why [ bleep ] -- we were supposed to be on vacation this week, man. i was really looking forward to spending my life with this chick. >> but he usually described her in pronouns such as "chick" or "that chick" or something to that effect. which was very unusual. >> reporter: eddie meeks is one of the prosecutors convinced mead is the killer. >> we knew he didn't trust her. and that was in direct contradiction to his "love of my life" story. >> reporter: and police say mead was suspicious and jealous, pointing to this exchange. >> when you were suspicious of lucy a little bit -- >> yeah, i just -- >> when she would have been --

>> wanted to make sure she wasn't somebody else there banging her on something -- >> and she was banging somebody, what would you do? >> i'd walk out. >> reporter: it was a tense few hours for mead. >> you are the one who is not telling us anything. >> i tell you what, man. this conversation's over. okay? i'm done with this [ bleep ]. i had nothing to [ bleep ] do with this. >> he seemed to enjoy the -- the cat-and-mouse game so to speak. >> reporter: in fact, for police, mike mead was his own worst enemy. they interview lucy's best friend deana bradshaw who tells them about an odd conversation she had with mead the day after the murder. >> he was in too good of a mood. he was laughing. he was happy. he is talking about lucy's breasts, and how he was going to miss them. he was not sad that he just lost his fiance. >> reporter: mead's behavior is enough to raise suspicion with lucy's family. at lucy's memorial service, her uncle says mead made more inappropriate comments. this time, about a 17-year-old relative.

>> mike leaned over and said, "man, i'd sure like to have me some of that." this was at lucy's -- >> reporter: at the funeral? >> at her memorial service. the love of his life, as he called her. he was acting like he was at a party. >> reporter: as prosecutors ready for trial, they work to build a case that mike mead has a history of rough encounters with women he has dated. more than a dozen women who say mike was vindictive, aggressive, pushy and outright creepy. >> you start to hear things like he has a pattern. a pattern of meeting women online. a pattern of relationship that seems strong and then all of a sudden it turns really bad. >> reporter: a key witness for the prosecution, best friend deana bradshaw, says mike and lucy fought constantly about her pregnancy. mike, she says, wanted her to get an abortion. >> he never believed that the baby was his. her feelings were hurt. that he did not want her to have the baby. >> reporter: odd behavior, a

possible pattern of aggressive encounters with women, and some circumstantial evidence. would it be enough? it's off to trial in charlotte, north carolina. >> this is about cold blooded premeditated murder. >> reporter: the prosecution tells the jury mike is on a mission to be done with lucy and the baby, and he wants his ring back. >> this was a $12,000 to $15,000 ring that mr. mead admittedly gave her. she's not the first person to have that ring but she definitely was the last. >> reporter: if it was going to end, he was going to take the diamond with him. >> reporter: police never find that diamond but they were excited about another find at the house. the gold standard of evidence, dna. the fire at lucy's house did not burn everything. evidence technicians are able to recover dna inside lucy.

diane turbyfill covered the trial for "the gaston gazette." >> there was some biological evidence of -- that michael mead had had sex with lucy johnson within about 24 hours of her death. >> reporter: why does that matter? prosecutors say mead denied having sex with her that night but police say he did and dna proves it. what's more, they say it was rape. >> lucy would not have had sex with him willingly. >> lucy was pregnant and she had a condition that made having sex dangerous for the health of the baby. >> reporter: it was a flashpoint in mike mead's police interrogation. he is vehement the sex was consensual and several days before the murder. >> but you said you had sex with her after that. >> really, because she begged and -- >> you still had sex. >> i don't know. >> come on. >> no, but -- it was super gentle. >> don't give us a bunch of crap

that you didn't do this when you clearly did. >> reporter: at trial, prosecutors aren't finished. they have a blockbuster surprise. a star witness who tells jurors, "hold on." mike mead, he says, confessed to him. that's right. outright admitted he pulled the trigger that killed lucy johnson. lucy's uncle can barely believe his years. >> he said that mike mead told him that he didn't mean to shoot her the first time. that he just shot at her to scare her and it hit her. and it freaked him out so bad because she was jerking around and that he went and shot her again in the back of the head. >> reporter: the prosecution ran with that. >> she reached out to him and said, "oh, my god. you shot me. mike, please don't let me die." >> reporter: powerful, huh? but there is a problem. that star witnes, he has a bit of a credibility issue. you see, he is a convicted child rapist who says mead told him all this while both were locked up together for a short time in county jail. >> i've never confessed to a cop. i've never confessed to my lawyers.

i've never confessed to anybody because i'm not going to confess to something i didn't do. but i'm going to confide in a guy who raped a girl. >> reporter: as the prosecution closes its case, is the deck stacked against mike mead, or is it a house of cards? next, the murder victimch thes from the grave. lucy's journal names a suspect. >> i mean, she wrote it down. >> reporter: it's a former boyfriend, but which one? [ femn there's a gap out there. that's keeping you from the healthcare you deserve. at humana, we believe if healthcare changes, if it becomes simpler... if frustration and paperwork decrease... if grandparents get to live at home instead of in a home... the gap begins to close. so let's simplify things. let's close the gap between people and care. ♪ let's close the gap between people and care. the winged drama k? with lasting drama gel liner

from maybelline new york. super-concentrated pigments in an oil-free gel. so easy. intense color that lasts up to 24 hours. lasting drama, on trend at eye studio now. ♪ maybe it's maybelline. ♪ ♪ ♪ for 4 days only... save an additional 15% storewide with coupon. go to petsmart.com/family for your coupon, valid june 5th through june 8th only. during the petsmart® friends & family event. inspire their new line of bbq pizza hut askpizzasto help

like blake's smokehouse bbq with a toasted cheddar crust and hardwood smoked bacon. try one for 11 and get a 2-liter pepsi for a buck more. order now! at pizza hut.com. now this is barbecue. sofa... desk... you know what?

why don't you go get some frozen yogurt. i got this. you're so sweet. you got this, right? i do got this. from the shelf, and to your home. starting at $99. [cell phone chime] yeah! [giggling excitedly] [splashing water] c'mon! (announcer) ready for a little fun? you could scratch your way to instant winning. play the pennsylvania lottery's new instant game, $1,000 frenzy, with 8 top prizes of $300,000. it's kinda fun to make a splash. keep on scratchin'.

sofa... desk... you know what? why don't you go get some frozen yogurt. i got this. you're so sweet. you got this, right? i do got this. from the shelf, and to your home. starting at $99. "20/20" continues with the burning bed. once again, jim avila. >> reporter: in the modern tower that is charlotte's mecklenburg county courthouse, the state of north carolina is working overtime to put mike mead to death for the murder of his pregnant fiance, lucy johnson. did you kill lucy? >> absolutely not. absolutely not. not one thing to do with lucy's death.

>> reporter: did mike mead murder lucy johnson? >> no, he didn't. >> reporter: and how do you know that? >> all the evidence says that he didn't. >> reporter: really? what about all those women prosecutors say mike mistreated. many of them at the end of the relationship were quite unhappy with you, right? they were angry at you. >> sure. i wouldn't doubt that. they said at my bond hearing that there was eighteen women that came forward and signed sworn affidavits of abuse, that i'm a violent person, and i challenge you to show one. not one. there's never been one complaint from any woman that i've ever been with that i've laid a hand on them physically. and are there girls out there that ended badly with? who hasn't? >> reporter: but you never hit any of them? >> never. >> reporter: never threatened them? >> never. never stalked any of them, never burned any of their houses. never raped anybody, nothing. >> the expectation coming from the d.a.'s office is that we're going to hear a lot of these women. >> reporter: but the jury never hears that. >> we don't see not one of these women take the stand.

>> reporter: that's right. the judge ruled that their stories were inadmissible, irrelevant because none of those women had ever accused him of a crime. okay, but what about the engagement ring, the so-called blood diamond? prosecutors say its part of the motive. mead was done with lucy, didn't want that baby and wanted his ring back. >> it's a $15,000 ring, just never was found. we thought -- we found that to be very, very strange. very odd. >> reporter: but it's not airtight, because it wasn't like it was found in mike mead's pocket nor his drawer or in his car. >> right. >> reporter: it just wasn't found. >> it just wasn't found. >> reporter: mike mead lives alone, so, on the night of the murder, there's no one but his dog to vouch for him. >> and when i went to bed that night, god knows i didn't think i needed an alibi. you know, if the dog had talked we'd be in good shape but you know, dogs can't talk. >> reporter: but mead offers police three electronic alibis. first -- he says his alarm system, as he demonstrated to us, shows he was at home all night. two -- his cell phone also puts

him at home all night. three -- he was playing madden nfl on playstation and the timestamp on the game places him at home at the crucial time. but how does mead answer the prosecution claim that the dna evidence proves he forced sex with lucy on the night of the murder and lied about it? mead's defense investigator steve ehlers admits if the dna found in lucy was fresh, mike was there that night and murdered her. >> the perpetrator goes in, rapes her, shoots her, burns her house down. >> reporter: but on cross examination, the prosecution witness is forced to concede that critical dna may not be all that fresh and just as mike claimed, could have been from sex days before the murder. >> that semen was not the home run or the smoking gun they thought they were going to have. >> reporter: and if that isn't enough of a perry mason moment, listen up. the defense is granted a rare gift. the judge allows them to stand

up in open court, in front of the jury, and not only proclaim mike mead's innocence, they get to point their finger at the man they say is the real killer. >> in north carolina, the rule is pretty strict, you can't do that. unless you have got direct evidence pointing to the guilt of someone else -- relevant evidence. >> reporter: unleashed, the defense turns prosecution and puts jim spelock on trial. starting with his alibi, that he was at his house with his baby, his roommate didn't hear him leave, and there was a woman who first told police spelock and she were texting all night. but then revised her story. >> did i think it was weird that he sent me a text at 3:00, yes. >> okay. >> it was out of character for him. >> she showed back up at the police department and said, he didn't text me all night. actually, he stopped texting me for two and a half hours. ironically, at the two and a half hours when lucy was being killed and her house was being set on fire. >> reporter: in fact, by the time of the trial, lucy has been

dead for three years. but now the jury is about to hear from her again. that's right. lucy becomes the star witness at her own murder trial. offering stunning testimony from the grave. written in this pink polka dot notebook. a journal lucy kept to build a custody case against jim spelock >> lucy told us over and over again in her own words who she thought she was in danger from. >> reporter: and it wasn't just all about that pink notebook. the prosecution witness, deana bradshaw, reluctantly delivered some devastating evidence in mike mead's favor. >> and she said, "well, if anything happens to me, you know who did it." and so she was referring to jim spelock. but it was all in laughter. >> reporter: laughed it off, maybe. but then she brought it up again. but she had said, "well, remember what i said," you know, referring to if she's killed,

that jim spelock did it. and we were laughing and she left. that was the night she was murdered. >> reporter: and in that pink notebook, lucy also documents accounts of spelock's online gambling and an interest in cross-dressing that extended to buying sexual paraphernalia on the internet while he was supposed to be working at the nuclear power plant. >> just about two weeks before her death, for the first time ever, she was able to document, to actually document on the computer, that he was purchasing these items. >> reporter: documentation lucy had just turned over to her custody lawyer days before her death. >> mr. spelock was aware that she had the proof of her allegations. >> reporter: that's the defense case. jim spelock murdered lucy johnson because she was about to win the custody case and reveal his darkest secrets. how more definitive can you be? >> that's another reason why at first we felt like it was him.

but i've learned -- don't jump to conclusions. he was perfect person to be framed for a crime. >> reporter: jim spelock turned down our requests for an interview, but denies he murdered lucy or bought women's clothes for himself. and prosecutor eddie meeks believed him. >> regardless of all these different arrows pointing, all these red herrings, at the end of the dashy, when you weigh al the evidence, it was only one arrow and it pointed at michael mead. >> reporter: but who does the jury believe? >> what would you make of those writings in lucy's journal, enough to influence how you'd vote on the jury? let us know on twitter, use #abc2020. you'll hear from that jury when we come back for the first time, revealing why they decided what they did, right here on "20/20." we'll be right back. when "20/20" continues -- what the jury heard. what they thought. and their bombshell verdict, based on lucy's journal. >> i mean, she wrote it down.

>> but which name did she write? next. replace your laptop? start with the best writing experience. make it incredibly thin. add an adjustable kickstand, a keyboard, a usb port, and the freedom of touch. and, of course, make it run microsoft office, with the power and speed to do real work. introducing surface pro 3. the tablet that can replace your laptop. meet new dream pure bb . from maybelline, new york. our first 8-in-1 bb with blemish-fighting salicylic acid conceals and reduces blemishes for healthy-looking, clearer skin. new dream pure bb ♪ maybe it's maybelline.

know that chasing performance and fewer choices in retirement. know that proper allocation could help increase returns so you can enjoy that second home sooner. know the right financial planning can help you save for college and retirement. know where you stand with pnc total insight. a new investing and banking experience with personalized guidance and online tools. visit a branch, call or go online today.

"20/20" continues. here again, jim avila. >> reporter: lucy johnson's 34th birthday, if she had lived. and for her fiance, mike mead, judgment day. the jury announces they have reached a verdict after nearly nine hours deliberation. >> well, i am always terrified while i am waiting for a jury. you can never be sure. people ask criminal defense attorneys all the time, "how can

you defend somebody that you know is guilty?" trust me, it is much harder to defend someone when you truly believe they are innocent. >> reporter: and here it is. the verdict. >> michael mead, not guilty. >> members of the jury, thank you very much for your work on this case. >> reporter: not guilty on all counts. mike mead goes from dead man walking to find me the nearest exit. >> just thank god that i'm here. i fully expected not guilty. >> reporter: why were you not surprised when they said not guilty? >> because i had set in the same trial for seven weeks that they had. >> reporter: and? >> and if it was sitting on that jury, i would have been going, you know, what in the world is going on with this case? >> reporter: so "20/20" gathered 11 jurors and returned them to their cemenseats in the same

courtroom, for their first group interview, where it was clear that the defense strategy worked. >> i don't understand how they were able to come to trial to not even give a second look at jim spelock. >> reporter: a key element for the jury -- lucy's own words in her journal. so lucy johnson, herself, told you, a juror, jim spelock did it. >> if anything were to happen to me, spelock did it. i mean, she wrote it down. >> he wanted that son named after him, and she wouldn't do it. >> reporter: and they thought spelock had motive. the women's clothing lucy said he bought for himself. >> james spelock was backed into a corner at this point. >> i think -- desperate, in that he needed to stop that from being out in public. >> reporter: the jurors tell us, in all of lucy's messages from the grave, they found not one word against mike mead. >> there was never any entry in any of her journals about him

doing anything aggressive to her at all. >> i thought the state was really grasping at straws. >> the evidence was overwhelming, as far as mike mead not doing it. >> reporter: and that's hard to hear, isn't it? >> that's hard to hear. >> reporter: the jurors saved their harshest criticism for the police. comparing them to a classic fictional north carolina law enforcement bafoon. >> i called him barney fife, in my mind. we got a bunch of barney fifes. >> i think barney was smarter. >> they didn't have a clue. >> they blew it. and i think that's what bother mes about this case the most. and we do have a horrendous murder case, that has not been solved. it believes you wondering. >> reporter: so whether it was bad police work or prosecuting the wrong man, or perhaps the perfect crime that allowed mike mead to get away with murder, one thing for sure -- no one thinks lucy johnson got justice. since mike mead has been tried and acquitted, and since you

don't believe that there's anybody else out there that could have done the crime, lucy will never get justice, in your mind. >> not in my mind. >> reporter: today, jim spelock has full custody of his son cason, who after lucy's death, he renamed james spelock iii. mike mead says although he is free, he lives under a cloud of suspici suspicion. we interviewed meeks, okay? to this day he thinks you did it. >> well, to this day he's an idiot. >> where there's smoke, there's fire. >> the evidence is clear. i have no respect for meeks. so, you know, what meeks thinks i don't really care. what i think matters is what the 15 jurors that heard the evidence think. >> reporter: mead has moved from south to north carolina, trying to live a new life. did it bother you that even though you were aacquitted, thee are people to this day that believe you got away with murder?

>> well, sure. it's excruciating. >> reporter: right now, mead is in the middle of an open lawsuit charging his civil rights were violated, and he was falsely prosecuted by the gaston county police. the police say they cannot comment on a pending legal matter. do you ever close your eyes and think about like if none of this happened. where would you life be with lucy right now? do you do that? >> oh, yeah, of course. yeah, i would have a wife, a beautiful wife, a little boy, yeah. >> reporter: you miss her? >> yeah, i miss her. >> reporter: the home where lucy lived and died, today, just a vacant lot. a driveway that leads to nowhere. like the dead end investigation into her murder. anything help at all? >> no.

just my faith in god, that one day, the person that did this will have to face him, face another judge. >> reporter: where all the evidence will be in. >> right. nothing's hidden from him. it'll be exposed. [ telephone ringing ]

♪ [ female announcer ] is your morning trying to tell you something? maybe we should have gotten him one? [ female announcer ] sweet, creamy iced coffee from mcdonald's. another reason to love mccafé. [ female announcer ] sweet, creamy iced coffee from mcdonald's. adore. crave. color elixir, the first creamy lip lacquer, from maybelline new york. intense color. mesmerizing shine. a cushiony feel. everything lips love in just one sweep. color elixir. maybe it's maybelline. ♪ show 'em the curve. it's beautiful. it's more than that...

...it's perfect. introducing curved ultra high definition television from samsung. [ female announcer ] you never know what might come your way. a 24-speed bike with 7 gears you will never use. an aquarium for the fish you named but shouldn't have. because you know, fish. a snowboard that'll carve a mountain like it was a thanksgiving turkey. whatever comes your way, the ford escape with its foot-activated liftgate will help you bring it home. ♪ and we're back tonight with a first look at that extraordinary interview. diane sawyer, one-on-one with hillary clinton, nothing off the table. from benghazi to her real relationship with president obama. from her health to her marriage. and when will we all know if she's running? >> hillary clinton, face to face

with diane sawyer. >> we know all of the historic and political currents that might be driving you to say yes. >> right. >> what is the strongest reason to say no? >> from her family -- >> is this the happiest time in your marriage? >> to her health. >> you would release your medical records? >> she talks about it all. >> monica lewinsky is back in the news. >> hillary clinton. public and private. >> time for radical candor? >> that's monday night, 9:00 eastern on the eve of her new book, "hard choices." hillary clinton answering the hard questions from diane. nothing off-limits. that is "20/20" for tonight. i'm david muir. for elizabeth and all >> and up next the sixers get the ball rolling to build a new

practice facility in camden and >> we are talking about practice man, what are we talking about, practice? >> yup, that's what we're talking about allen. your old team wants to