ukrainian charity a judge now ordering her to remain bar behind bars for an additional three months, at least. but karelina has been able to exchange letters with her boyfriend here in the since her arrest. and tonight he is giving us the very latest on her life in prison. and what she is enduring they get to shower once a week >> that >> breaks me she has no hot water. the hardest thing for us to fall asleep because they refused to put the lights off. i can tell you this from the lettuce and stuff. she's scared she is scared and alone. >> one >> thing that gives chris hope he says is the cosine. it doesn't actually have to wear a prison uniform and thanks so much for joining us. we appreciate your being with us. it's time now for a 60 tonight

on three 60, there's breaking news and exclusive interview with >> arizona's democratic governor after the state's highest court reinstitute a near-total abortion ban that's more than a century old more breaking news tonight, the former president loses a key battle in his classified documents case. why the fight over revealing the names of potential witnesses is such an important win for the special counsel and later new bodycam video reveals what happened during a fatal encounter between chicago police officers and a 26 year-old man during a traffic stop. good evening. we start with a breaking news in the fall while out from the arizona supreme court decision that has even some top republicans in a state that could decide both the presidency and the senate saying it goes too far, the ruling scraps of 15 week limitation on abortion in the state and re-instituted a civil war era near total ban that was enacted before arizona was a state and before as vice president harris and others pointed out today hey women had the right to vote in the, the four to decision is a direct result, obviously, of the us supreme court overturning roe v. wade. that of course

provided federal protections for abortion with those ghana's now up to individual states to decide their own laws, which is what the arizona court did today. and it's something the former president just yesterday said he wasn't supportive my view is now that we have abortion where everybody wanted it from a legal standpoint. the states will determine by vote or legislation, or perhaps both. and whatever they decide must be the law of the land in this case the law of the state. many states will be different. many will have a different number of weeks or some will have more conservative than others. and that's what they will be at the end of the day. this is all about the will of the people in arizona, the implications for women are obviously massive. the law, if it survives, potential challenges would place arizona alongside states like texas and alabama as having some of the strictest anti-abortion laws of the country for abortion providers in violation of the law, if it goes into effect, it means a

possible jail sentence of two to five years and finds there's just some of the practical implications. there are obvious political implications as well. arizona as a swing state, abortion is a major issue animating the race there and just about everywhere in the country. just listen to what some undecided female voters in arizona told are randi kaye when she talked to them a few weeks ago before this new decision >> i don't know why the hell women's reproductive rights or even a political converse amen >> i could converse >> ai, look at the end of the day we? have to do, you know, potential president's like you have no business up in my body back and it's not only reproductive rights there now it's talking about ivf. what is next? i do not want anyone a government official who is a non-doctors, not part of my medical team telling me what i can and cannot do to my body or what is right for my body, how important our reproductive rights and freedoms to you in terms of choosing a candidate that's my top issue for all of

you >> i think it's definitely on the top one or two and the timelines coming up where me and my husband wanted to start trying and i'm scared for when i start trying and something happens. and if i have to make that choice unless either to die or doctors will go to jail. >> yeah. yeah. >> it may be weeks or longer before the log law goes into effect. the political fallout began immediately. vice president harris posted a video statement on social media calling on congress to restore the protections under roe shells. instead, she traveled arizona on friday to address issues surrounding reproductive rights kari lake, the republican election denier, who lost and gubernatorial race there seems to have done a one at she'd once praised the near total ban that's now law today. she's now running for senate in the state. she said she opposed it and said that arizona's governor katie hobbs and the state legislature

should come up with a quote, common sense solution arizona governor katie hobbs joins us now for her first interview since the decision given a hobbes, i appreciate you being with us. were you surprised by the decision today and what's your message to women in arizona tonight? >> well, arizonans across the state are reeling from this decision that reinstates the most ukrainian ban in the country. this is a ban that as you said, was passed in 18, 64 before we are state before women had the right to vote and it is a near total ban with no exceptions for rape or incest. it requires prison time for doctors and there's just right now, a lot of confusion about what is the current state who has access to what and it is, this is very harmful decision for arizonans. >> i want to talk about with the legislature may do, but but before that, i mean, can you clarify right now, when

assuming there's no action by the legislature when this law would be enforceable because while the state supreme courts stayed its ruling pending further arguments in a lower court, the majority opinion says, and i quote, positions are now a notice that all abortions except those necessary to say people woman's life are illegal. so what is the timeline here >> as you can imagine, there's still a lot of folks trying to figure this out we think it's 45 days, but certainly don't want to say that and make people think that they won't be penalized for something that happens before that we just start sure. and we need clarity >> what do you think do you think the legislature was that will act. i mean, republicans control both houses in arizona well, i've been calling on the legislature to repeal this archaic ban from day one of my administration, i >> renewed that call at the beginning of this legislative session. the fact is that some of the republicans, right now who are saying that this decision went too far are the

same politicians who celebrated the dobbs decision, which paved the way for this court ruling today and the speaker of the house and the senate president both weighed in. in this case with amicus brief urging the court to do exactly what it did today. >> so you in your attorney general, i know have taken steps to try to prevent county district attorney's from prosecuting anyone under this law do you expect county officials are going to try to take it a chord over that. what would happen in the meantime? >> well, today there hasn't been any test of that executive order which i am firmly believe is legally sound and it just prevents an extreme county attorney from using this ban to criminalize women and doctors for seeking the qarrah, providing the care that their patients need. and would provide consolidation with the attorney general. it hasn't

been tested yet. and i am hopeful that it doesn't have to be because this ban, this extreme ban is going to prevent people from getting care that they need. >> you've said, people across the strait are outraged about this and there's certainly a lot of outrage, but you just named a couple of people who are actually for this. what do you say to those in arizona in your state i believe this is a good idea >> like arizonans are going to be able to weigh in on this and enshrine abortion in our state's constitution in november. and i am confident that when given the opportunity, they will vote to protect abortion access. >> do you think that will get on the ballot? for this election >> well, on their way, there, they have surpassed the number of signatures needed and they still have months to continue collecting and this is a common sense measure that is supported by the vast majority of arizonans in terms of

protecting access and certainly it's going to motivate voters in november i'm concerned about people's care between now and november, and i'm going to do everything in my power to ensure that arizonans can get the care that they need. but these extreme politicians are absolutely out of touch with what arizonans and not only will arizonans have the chance to weigh it on this ballot measure, but they'll also have a chance to elect new legislators who will fight to protect their freedoms. and instead of taking them away, as you know, the former president from president trump's campaign said tonight and i quote president trump could not have been more clear. these are decisions for people of each state to make. what do you say to that >> well, it is really unconscionable that folks in arizona now are going to have to go to nevada, california, new mexico, or colorado to get the care that they need. and i'm glad there's organizations that are going to be helping them do that. but people across the country treat

americans should not have unequal access to their freedoms. and we need to work to restore those in arizona. >> do you think they're going to be moos against ivf now in the state? >> absolutely. >> these >> extreme legislators, sent a fetal personhood bill to my desk that i was able to veto last year. this is a bill that would have paved the way for an alabama style ruling that would ban ivf in arizona. they're going after contraception this doesn't stop at abortion there's one governor, katie hobbs. i appreciate your time. thank you >> thank you. so now >> by maggie hebrew, senior political correspondent, the new york times and frank lunch, a republican pollster and communication strategies. so magazine we mentioned the foreign presence campaign said the position is that should be up to the state's. does he think? >> i mean, he clearly thought he could leave it at that yesterday, avoid maybe taking a position on your total bans like arizona's that does not include exceptions for rape and incest anderson, i think that

he and his aides thought that he was going to have more than a day of buying time with that >> statement yesterday, a statement that was not clarifying. i mean, it was it was saying that it should or will be left up to the states. he didn't address where he is on a federal ban or if he would sign a federal ban of such a thing were to pass. however steep the odds are in washington, if he were president. and so now he's going to have to address this span. the argument from democrats and the biden campaign is by saying that it's up to all states to pick what they want to do. trump has endorsed all bands and this this news out of arizona is really going to test that as far as i know, he has not commented yet. there are a lot of people eagerly waiting to hear what he has to say >> how do you think this plays out from in terms of politics, that's the worst issue for the republicans right now. they have a double-digit lead on inflation, a double-digit lead on immigration if they're talking about abortion, democrats have 15 to percent

advantage. so for trump talking about this, engaging in any of the details is a negative same thing for the republicans and if you notice the governor, i pay attention to words and she talked extreme extreme. she must have said it half a dozen times. that's going to be the narrative over the next several months that this is an extreme position which it is but they're trying to use abortion as a way to communicate the republican party is being outside the mainstream. it's a good democratic issue and that, that messaging, that language, do you think that's effective for democrats, its >> effective for democrats. it's less effective for independent but in the end, the independence in swing voters, they're looking for economic issues, they're looking for quality of life issues. young women, this is the number one issue for young women. their right to choose trump's. sorry for the language. it trump's every other issue so in terms of get-out-the-vote, in terms of winning in these close states abortion could do for

the democrats exactly what it did in 2022 republicans were expecting a 20 see gain. they didn't get it because young women voted on abortion back then, and they're going to do the same now. >> megan former president, has probably told allies in the past that he believes abortion is equipped political loser. i mean to frank point, if republicans are talking about it, it's they're losing. do you have a sense of oh worried they are tonight about arizona? >> this is something that is certainly on their minds about how to deal with it. i mean, i will note that the one out that trump may take is that he stressed in his video and he has said this in private discussions with people and public does public commentary. his focus on exceptions in terms of rape, incest, and life of the mother. and this bill this new law would have no exceptions and that might be an off-ramp that he takes, but regardless, i mean, yes, trump said and we have the times broke this. the trump was saying to people when the likely dobbs decision was

impending, that this was going to be bad for republicans he has recognized that the politics of this are bad for republicans. he has also then gone out and said that he proudly helped overturn roe v. wade. and so it's a little hard to have it both ways, but he is trying to have it always and he often does. he tries to leave all options open and avoid being pinned down. this is on a significant issue that a lot of women are very, very animated by and looking as if you are trying to avoid saying anything. i don't think it's going to be a sustainable position for him. >> how break, how does the trump campaign avoid talking about this issue >> by going back to the border? my going back to prices and he's good at that the public is deeply concerned about affordability. and i'm not ducking your question. i'm actually emphasizing affordability matters to every family immigration because of the results of what's happened at the border matters to everyone abortion is a hardcore issue for younger women, a little bit less so for younger

men and the older that you get, it's still important. but it's not a voter driven issue with, as these other ones are in mega man, if trump is elected in november, do you think he would change the positions support a federal abortion ban? i mean, i guess there's i mean, of course he's certainly open to changing its position >> all right. >> anderson, i think that's i think that's the point and i think that's what you will hear democrats say and point to a law that trump has been in several different places on abortion now he does have credibility with ev angelic goals because of what he did in terms of appointing conservative justices to the supreme court. and throughout the federal courts, those jobs let's, this on the supreme court overturned roe v. wade. that was something trump said in 2016. he was going to do >> that did happen. and so trump believes that he has enough credibility to not really take a stand here, but trump has historically reverted on the issue to turning the issue over to conservative activists who are against abortion. and so i don't think anyone should assume that they

have any idea what he would do on this as precedent >> he also had evangelicals. you have a former vice president pence coming out saying this was a slap in the face yesterday when he said that do you think that actually matters at this stage, the trump campaign, i mean, is that is that where were they going to go if they don't vote for trump, he's got the evangelical, no matter what happens in his life, he's proven that evangelicals will stand behind him no matter what happens in his life, he's proven that it economic conservatives can trust them and economic issues, social consertives, but in the end, it's that centeit's th5% o haven't made up their mis. they tend to be younger, rather than der. they tend to be a little less educate with less likely ollow the news and for these people and issue li abortion matters ttle bit more than the population overall.hat's what 'm focuseon undecided voters. and is is going to plabig time among younger women and clients.

>> thanks so much. megan haberman, as welcome. have a breaking news and the former president classified documents, case while the judge is saying tonight about the potential witnesses in that case, and the former president trying again to delay his historic criminal trial in manhattan with just six days until it starts. i'll talk it over with cnn's kara scannell, who was in the courtroom today, as well as our legal team. and then later at michigan, judge has sentenced the parents of a high school shooter who killed four students details on their precedent-setting punishments after being convicted of involuntary manslaughter. and also the emotional victim impact statements read by the families >> it's easy to think that all money managers are pretty much the same but if fisher investments were clearly different, different how you saw high commission investment products, right? >> no, for sure. avoid sin. >> well, you must earn commissions on trains never at fisher investments. >> okay. and then you probably sneak in some hidden and layered feats no, we structure our v, so we do better when clients do better, that might bebe why most of our clients coe from other money managers.

fisher investments were clearly different and two options for you. take a look at >> it. >> when it's time for an update or complete remodel, want yourself there. >> so here you guys really everything down to the >> stomach, worry about this with you every step of the way. from design and products to removal and installation. okay >> what do you guys think it is, right? he handled the entire process decree get a beautiful and functional bathroom for whatever your life needs ray-ban with you every step of the way. color visit rebuffed.com for your free in-home design consultation one barbarous was the turbotax. >> i wrote for generations of family tradition. >> i want to make perfume >> so i meet barbers new psyche counts, like her maximum refund intuit turbotax's you're surrounded just going to send oh, are you going to take your lord

>> we're going to take it back in to take it, which scott's tarrif builder terrific action. it gets three jobs done at one's kills reads prevents cab gas, and keeps your lawn growing strong the laureus >> no >> get a bag of scott's triple action today. >> it's guaranteed fee. >> feed it he there, brenda >> it's carroll exactly. >> so which like are we operating on? >> you mean arm >> it's all connected, asking the right question can greatly impact your future. >> you share your an orthopedist. >> actually, i'm a sagittarius, especially when it comes to your finances. >> give a question are you a certified financial planner? >> yes. i'm a cfp professional cop >> professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. that's why it's gotta be a cfp. bind your cfp professional, and let's make a planned out or when enamel is gone, you cannot get it back, but you can repair it with pronoun will repair it penetrates deep into the two to actively repair acid, we again, the enamel i recommend pronoun will repair with new pronoun

will repair mouthwash. you can enhance that repair beyond brushing. they work great together

d the world saved 20% for a limited time >> this source with kaitlan collins tonight at nine breaking news in the classified documents case against the former president of federal judge in the case, judge aileen >> cannon just made a key ruling and it has to do with the potential witnesses cnn's evan perez joins us now with that. so what did the judge decide? >> what edison she decided that she agrees now, with special counsel jack smith to keep protected some of the names the names of witnesses, key witnesses jack smith the special counsel, had argued that they should be protected because they could be subject to intimidation and threats, which of course we've seen in some cases associated with the former president. and so she

had previously indicated that she was inclined to let those names be be put in public records in some of the filings by the trump team, which of course would cause problems for them but one of the part of the story here, anderson, is the continued back-and-forth sharp back-and-forth between jack smith and the judge. you and i call it i talked about it last week and i said, it's getting done right. saskya, you see some of that today in this filing where she said that some of the arguments that they made, they should have made from the beginning and not belatedly. >> did judge kennedy leave room for release of witness names in the future >> she did. she said for now, these names will be will be redacted in any filings that are made. she did say that the special counsel seems to want to make this on long-term thing. and so she she allowed for her to change her mind later on. >> and does this impact any records in the case becoming

public >> well, she also ruled that more records indicates are going to be made public but if any of those records implicate the names or might identify some of these witnesses and she's asking for that information to be redacted. so in both cases the jack smith got some of what he was asking for it which is to protect the names, the trump team got some of what they wanted, which is for more of these records to be made public. jw anderson let's have been thanks so much now to the former president's hush money criminal case here in new york today, he was rejected yet again, in another attempt to delay the case. that's set to start on monday with jury selection. this time the decision came from an appeals court judge just minutes after hearing arguments joining me now are former federal prosecutors, jennifer and temidayo aganga-williams. he was also senior investigative counsel for the house select january 6 committee, also seen as kara scannell, who was in the courtroom today. so what happened in the appeals courts >> yes. so this is trump's latest attempt to try to stop this trial before it starts today, they were in their asieh and appellate judge to hold the

trial to stop it so they could challenge the gag order that was put in place restricting trump's statements. and there were brief arguments on this. it was quickly denied. but this is just one of a flurry of filings that we're seeing both at the trial court level and at the appellate level to try to stop this case there are three court days left before this is over and before the trial starts and i think we could possibly see more, but even this is not technically over because they will file briefs for an appellate court panel to consider this. those briefs are due on monday, which is the start of this trial decision is expected to follow. it's still a long shot for him to stop this case right now. >> i mean, to me die one of the arguments, the trump team is making is that will new york the jury pool is likely to be you are more likely to be liberal, perhaps, and not like trump does that argument hold any water? would that mean that any politician on trial could only be tried in a district where he was popular yeah.

>> i mean, you get to have a jury of your peers and the president famously from new york. and what the jury process about is about gleaning who is going to be fair and impartial process. it's not about getting the jury's which you only want. it's about having the opportunity to ask them questions to really inquire whether they could be fair and impartial to both parties. he's both the government and the defendant have a right to a fair trial. he's going to have the opportunity here. the judge will ask questions. council to have the opportunity to ask questions. and these very issues about political affiliation preconceptions about the former president. all of that is going to have an opportunity to come out and then it will have the opportunity to do what people do and every trial with just a strike jurors. i mean, every lawyer who's been to trial before, is engaged in that process. you're trying to understand what are people's preconceived notions about your positions. and then you test those. and if you don't feel confident they're going to support you and your ultimate arguments. you have those jury struck, so we have that chance. >> and jennifer, i mean, we saw the jury some of the questions is going to be asked to the

jury buried. you'd it's going to be i mean, do you think it's gonna be a lengthy process funding jury? >> i think it will because there's so many people involved. i mean, they're going to call hundreds of people because there's so many people were going to say they feel strongly about trump, either against him or for him. and the judge has already said that all people who say i have a conflict or i just can't be fair and impartial are going to automatically be get used. but saying it's gonna take them a long time to get through all of these hundreds of people, even with a streamline process which includes a questionnaire and not going one by one through all the people who say that they, they have a copy her specifically about the gag order. what did his legal team take issue with? >> so they said they wanted to narrow it in three different ways. they said that they thought trump should be able to talk about michael cohen and stormy daniels, two key witnesses for the prosecution because they said that they are continuing to talk about the case. they want him to have the ability to respond. they also said that they think trump should be able to talk about publicly filed motions in this case. one of them is about vr accusing the judge and that motion which had the details

about the work his daughter was has done for democratic organization came the day after the gag order was put in place. so he's trying to get around the gag order that way by saying, let me talk about this motion and then also he wants to talk about one of the prosecutors on the case who for a brief period of time worked at the department of justice as part of his line that this is a biden prosecution and even though the district attorney, alvin bragg is entirely separate from the department of justice, and it's not taking direction from joe biden and he wants to loosen the gag order and that way the prosecutor said no, that this gag order is already narrowly tailored and they said that they're already having challenges with some witnesses who don't want to testify, even just about records good keeping in the case because of the fear of what trump could possibly say against them and what his followers could possibly then react with jan, one of the, one of the foreign presence attorneys made the argument that the sum of the form prison statements about the case may be rude, but they didn't rise the level of incitement. >> yeah, that's the understatement of the year,

right? don't have to rise to the level of incitement they are they are intimidating. they are threatening, they are as karatay said, making people not want to participate in the trial. and the judge has an obligation to protect the integrity of those proceedings. and so this gag order, which by the way, very similar language, was upheld by the dc circuit federal court of appeals so when it was put in place by judge chutkan and the other the federal election subversion case. so there's really strong ground to stand on to say that this was a constitutional order. and i think it stand up until the >> on the judge cannon decision about keeping the jury for now. the names of are from becoming public, but at least at this juncture, what do you make of that? >> here? i think there's been a confrontation between the department of justice and judge cannon that has been building. and the question of whether you had is an understatement, but i think you saw her back down and try to save face here i mean, she really said she's suggested that jack smith it introduced new evidence that you could consider. i think what's happened here is that he told her what the law was and she had no choice but to agree with

them. but i think this is just the beginning and rolex you that confrontation which is going to have to be decided by the leopard circuit, which is the appellate court that oversees judge cannon. and remain the future. see an attempt by jack smith to have her removed. >> she can be removed. >> i think if she makes if she continues on the path which she has, i think has had some undefendable decisions as she he's made. and i think if she does that again, i do think we will see that possibility going forward >> fascinating. i appreciate it, everyone. thank you. just ahead. emotional impact statements today in the historic sentencing and the parents of a michigan school shooter, are you going to hear them? and i'll talk to the lead prosecutor on the case that's next. >> well, i have moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. thanks to sky rosie, i'm on my way with clearer skin. >> three and four 90% clear skin at four months. and sky breezy is just four doses a year after to starter doses. >> serious allergic reactions and an increased risk of infections or alone for our ability to fight them may occur. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms had a vaccine or plan to

nothing on my skin mean everything >> you're goodman just about sky rosie, learn how api can help you save. >> there are over $7 us businesses on tiktok. >> my name is dana bell phi and my husband and i own the village bakery and our mission is to employ people with different abilities tiktok is allowing us to show what acceptance looks like. >> this is a community of just complete and utter luck. >> it's the people that lift you up when you're down, people on tiktok do that on a daily basis and i've never found a community like that ever >> keep tiktok >> imagine a future where plastic is not wasted. >> but instead >> remade over and over into the things that keep our food fresher our families safer and our planet cleaner to help us get there. america's plastic makers are investing billions of dollars to create innovative products and new recycling

technologies for sustainable change because when you push for smarter solutions make things can happen >> with this, let's romantics >> welcome. >> i'm your host checkup hi, i wish weather getting up here fine, but i think we're just going to go up too bad and we believe it goes mother is buried in the meanwhile, at a vrbo >> when other vacation rentals have no privacy, try one that has no one that you when you're the leader is ask the cleanup and restoration, how do you make like it never even happened? >> happened brandi

>> whatever comes your way. >> there's a pro for that. serve pro like it never even happened by 100% free with turbotax free edition, roughly 37% of taxpayers qualify form ten, 40, and >> limited credits only. see how it turbotax.com

recommend force vector rush to walmart on leash or potential with force backer >> ones left waiting for something new? in kept wanting more >> and there'll be tuesday on tbs is here >> quadrics hovers begins no 9:30 p.m. on tbs and there was an unprecedented and emotionally difficult day in court today is the parents of the michigan school shooter was sentenced to at least a decade in prison. james and jennifer crumbley's son killed four students in the 2021 shooting, and they became the first parents might be held criminally responsible for a mass shooting committed by their child. she an engine because ours has more it is the

sense of this court must crumbley that you serve ten to 15 years as to defendant james crumbley. it is a sense of this court that you serve ten to 15 years historic sentences handed down for the parents of a teen who killed four students at a michigan high school in 2021. >> that is the goal of sentencing to act as a deterrent. these convictions are not about four parenting these convictions confirm repeated acts or lack of x that could have halted an oncoming runaway train. >> james and jennifer crumbley were found guilty of involuntary manslaughter in separate trials earlier this year. the first-time parents have a mass school shooter have been held directly accountable for an attack on november 30, 2021. their son killed madison baldwin. tate, mere justin shilling and hana st. juliana at oxford high school using a

gan gifted to him by jennifer and her husband our children in your hands to family of the victims, gave statements ahead of the sentencing. >> when you worried about what people thought of human feeling threatened i was learning your son, threaten my daughter and field, fatally shot while you were hiding? >> i was >> planning her funeral and why you were running away from your son and your responsibilities? >> i was forced to do the >> worst possible thing, apparent good. do i was forced as they go by the way, madison the older sister of 14 year-old victim, hana st. juliana, says, no punishment will ever be enough. >> i now have to live with that hana, my little sister, my best friend, my other half to me that makes a maximum sentence being 15 years to shore honda even have 15 years to live how

does murder has destroyed large portion of my birth. >> both crumbleys spoke up on their own behalf james crumbley for the first time since his trial began to the victims and the families i saturday not to ask for your forgiveness, as i know it, maybe beyond breach but just rest my sincerest apologies for the pain that has been caused i will be in my own internal person for the rest of my life. >> i really wanted to families to know how truly how truly sorry i am. and i'll continue to feel this pain for the rest of my life as well >> if i >> could go back and change things if i could go back and do things differently and maybe none of us would be here today >> and because are assurances now are the crumbleys likely to appeal? i mean, could this be

their sentence reduced >> absolutely. they're going to appeal. we don't know how it will turn out, but you know, there are a lot of texts in this trial and texas, one moment of time, right. you don't know what happens before you don't know what happens after there were text by ethan in this trial, this shooter in this trial and where he texted his friend and he said, you know, i asked my dad for mental health and he laughed at me. he told me, just suck it up and take a pill. >> well, the crumbleys could not counteract that. there was nothing they wanted ethan to come in that courtroom to testify. so we could see what ethan had to say about all of that. and he had a fifth amendment privilege that is attorneys wave for him, did not waive saying that they are going to appeal his sentence. furthermore, the medical records because he told us psychiatrists that he actually they lied. he didn't ask his parents ever for any help. those medical records are privileged also, so they couldn't come in. so you saw one side, there was no way to counter it. by james and jennifer crumbley will see when an appellate court says about

that, because our thanks very much. >> i'm trying to me now is the lead prosecutor on the case, oakland county, michigan prosecutors your karen mcdonald, i'm ms mcdonald. i appreciate your time. you heard in genes report a sister of one of the victims, khan st. juliana, says that the ten to 15 years sentence for the crumbleys feels too short because hana, or sister didn't even live to be 15. are you satisfied with the sentences you you know, satisfaction isn't really a feeling that i think anyone has just watching this. your story. it's i haven't actually watched it since we were in court today and it is so jarring and moving and i think nothing will bring back these kids. but the sheer enormous impact that their gross negligence had on these families is just it was palpable. and if i could anderson, i would like to just address just the previous statements it is not actually

true that the shooter said the psychiatrist said he lied that that was taken completely out of context, and we heard that even today, which was a surprise that we'd be arguing facts after we've had to jury trials. >> but >> the shooter being called as a witness, and the psychiatrists actually would be damaging testimony for both parents. so the texas his friends or do you worry about what might happen on an appeal? are you confident >> i. do not because the we we were we took painstaking efforts and so did this, judge, to make sure that jennifer and james crumbley had a fair trial and the evidence that we start to admit, by the way, much much much of it was deemed excluded was went through the rigueur of an evidentiary analysis by the court and real argument and analysis by each side. but it

is not true that he told his psychiatrist that he lied about that. that's taken out of context and it's frustrating for us because all of this came out in the miller hearing, which is a separate proceeding we never sought to keep any of that information, but it's not ours to give. he does have a right. a fifth amendment right, and we couldn't give that, but it's just all of the evidence came out about what he actually told us psychiatrists and what his testimony would be and that's it's not favorable to jennifer james. >> i appreciate the clarification. what i mean, one of the important things that i mean, i'm not gonna say anything good can come out of this. but one of the important things perhaps that can come out of this is a message that could be santa parents everywhere, not just in michigan, but around the country about responsibility. >> and >> what do you hope that messages that's received by parents >> i don't think the majority of people in this country and

parents you're a parent. i'm a parent. need to have that message. i think the facts in this it's case are so egregious. i am absolutely not do not promote the idea that we should criminalize bad parenting. i absolutely don't stand for the proposition that we should always find out where the parent's role was and every criminal act, even if it's with a gun. but when you're presented with evidence like this, and you ask the question like all of us did where did the minor get the hands? his hands on his gun. and you those answers lead to social media posts boasting about it. they lead to a lot of signs that there were some trouble and ignoring that. and then an addition providing this deadly weapon, 40 days before the shooting, giving him access to the weapon and the ammunition not securing it. and then when called to the school and given this worksheet where he writes, helped me, the world is dead blood everywhere and

asked to get him some counseling, either that day or within 48 hours, and they say nothing about this gun. they were just i think the judges comments really stress that she sat through to very long detailed trials and her comments in sentencing really reflected a knowledge of the evidence and look, i i hope that what comes out of this is more questions about where the weapon comes from, more attention to access to weapons. but i want to be really clear. this prosecution does not really change the fact that the number one cause of death children this country is gun violence and we have to address it in a comprehensive public health way. i started and we're releasing recommendations on commission to address gun violence it goes way of stream

to talk about way before somebody puts their hand on a gun how can we prevent this? these tragedies and the good news is there's a lot of ways that we can prevent this. we just have to educate the public and provide that for them. >> karen mcdonald. i appreciate your time tonight. thank you >> thank you. >> just ahead. opposition to the former president's claims of immunity in his election interference case. this time from former top military commanders and officials, one of the 19th who signed an amicus brief to the supreme court join us next it's kubota orange days shot the year's biggest election of komodo equipment. hey, get 0% apr for 84 months, or up to 30 $300 off select compact tractors, find your nearest dealer at kubota orange days.com >> i met with the turbotax expert because i had two full-time jobs, lawyering and miami >> count on me, mia, i'll file your taxes for you with 100%

accuracy guaranteed. lead to turbotax full service expert, do your taxes as soon as today ? >> one in five children worldwide are faced with the reality of living without food no family dinners. >> a special treats, >> not enough energy to play all around the world. hunger is affecting children's physical and mental health toddlers are suffering from acute mt i'll nutrition, which stunt their growth. kids are forced to drop out of school so they can help support their families. conflict inflation and climate have ignited the worst famine in our lifetime. and we are fed up >> fed up that hunger devours dreams fed up that hunger destroys joy fed up with the fact that hunger eats childhood

help us feed the futures of children all over the world by visiting, get fed up now.org for as little as $10 a month. you can join save the children as we support children and families in desperate need of our help now is the time to get fed up and give back. when you join the cause you're $10 monthly donation can help communities in need of life-saving treatments and nutrients prevent children from dropping out of school support our work with communities and gun to help children go from short-term surviving to long-term thriving and now, thanks to special government grants, every dollar you give multiply up to ten times the impact >> that means more >> food, water, medicine, and help for kids around the world >> you'll also receive a free the tote bag to share your support for children in >> having >> your childhood eaten away by hunger is unimaginable. get fed

up >> call us >> now, or visit, get fed up now, today. >> home home yes >> focus on an american home. she had warranty. i can protect your covered home systems and appliances like this ac and when the repair or replacement? yes. thank you it's au not home. >> yeah, that's pretty sure it's home >> he just.com today for 40% off the ups stores, not just the ship and store where the shipping store >> the leave, the packing to what? store the we understand this is more than a package store where the packet shipping guaranteed store the piece of months we are the white around the corner, go to we should get all store the ups store be

unstoppable keep your private info price shred today at the ups store. >> we are rahm >> and when trucks or >> what do you do truck month. better than anyone else? you do trucks that work harder and play harder can you do trucks that when by breaking every rule of what a trucks should be. >> so this truck month would you should do is drive around trucks out. what we do during ram truck months, get new rollback manufacturers pricing with lower starting msrp is plus 1,000 bonus cash on 2024 ram heavy-duty trucks means night with abby phillip. tonight at tim eastern on cnn 19, former top military commanders and officials have filed a brief before the supreme court attacking the former president's claims of immunity. the authors include retired four-star admirals and generals, as well as your next guess, ray neighbors who served his naibe secretary in the obama administration and secretary maybe it's, it's good to have beyond you write in this amicus brief that a

president who had completed immunity from any action taken an office could mean, quote, creating the likelihood that service members will be placed in the impossible possible position of having to choose between following their commander in chief and obeying the laws enacted by congress. could you give us an example of an unlawful order, even if it was given by the commander-in-chief sure. >> you've got a you've got a president that has some unity that has no consequences for action then you've got a group of protesters peacefully protesting a policy of the administration and the president says tells us military, take them out. then the military if they follow that order they would be prosecuted for murder but they would have the impossible decision choice of do you follow an order from the commander in chief which is clearly unlawful? >> or >> do you follow your duty to

not obey that and cause the chaos that would that would fall. that's the that's the danger here and say serious deep, substantial danger. >> so it's not just theoretical. i mean, this could, you're saying but you believe it could have a ripple effect of having people in the military questioning orders that they receive from on high to make sure that i mean, just quite it would it would raise all sorts of questions and concerns about people in all different ranks >> absolutely. if one of the louk got to bedrock principals here, one is civilian control of the military. it's enshrined in our constitution. the other is that both civilians and the military operate under the rule of law and the thing that holds that together is trust. the military trust, the fact that the civilian superiors are going to

issue lawful orders if you have somebody who is not constrained by that prone, there's no consequences. and just says, i don't care if an orders lawful. i'm going to issue it. no matter what then once again, the militaries in that impossible position? do you follow an order this clearly unlawful or and they've got a duty to disobey if an order is unlawful, d followed that. >> but then what does that happen down the chain of command? what does the kernel do? what does the lieutenant do? what does sgt do? what does the private debt you've got the commander in chief saying one thing, you've got your military commit commanders and chain of command saying that the bag is the brief also says, and i quote, domestic conflict on us soil, especially conflict related to the peaceful transition of power only encourages are foreign adversaries what type of

national security threats do you envision if a foreign adversary were to take take advantage of a disruption in the united states >> one of the things that's the most awesome about our democracy is how we have a peaceful transfer of power. and every time we do, and we have for almost 250 years now in all sorts of situations, every time we do you have that transfer of power that time is a really fraught time because you've got a completely new group of people coming in they've got to be up to speed on day one, they're probably going to be tested. but if you've got someone issuing unlawful orders during that time, trying to hold on to power after an election that they lost. then foreign adversaries. they're going to seize on that. >> they already do. they >> already watch very closely? and test the us during these transitions. but if you've got this chaotic time and orders

being issued followed not followed then they could use that very easily as a time for either to move against us move against the allies, or to try to undermine us in myriad ways all around the world >> secretary mavis, i really appreciate you being on. thank you. >> thank you. anderson going up next and deadly >> police involved shooting in chicago and some questions about whether officers use excessive force will show you were newly released bodycam footage reveals about the moments leading up to the fatal encounter i have type two diabetes, but i'm it little pill with the big story to tell i take one jati easy >> jodi and sports 24/7 in your body to flush out some sugar and for adults with type two

diabetes and known heart disease, giardia is can lower the risk of cardiovascular death >> serious side effects may include ketoacidosis that may be fatal, dehydration that can lead to sudden worsening of kidney function and genital yeast or urinary tract infections a rare life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur, stuff dirty and somehow your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this infection ketoacidosis, or an allergic reaction, you may have increased risk for lower limb loss. call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of infection in your legs or feet, taking guardians, but this, we'll find urea or insulin may cause low blood sugar release file 100% free with turbotax free edition, roughly 37% of >> taxpayers qualify form ten, 40, and limited credits only see how it turbotax.com >> that's me >> you know, i spent a lot of time thinking about dirt at three in the morning and you're trying what people don't know. is that not all der is the

same. you need dirt with the right kind of nutrients look at this new organic soil from miracle grow. >> everybody should have it, it worked great for us. >> this is as good as gold in any garden. >> if people only >> knew that it really is about the sure. >> you're dirt nerd. huge turret nerd >> i'm proud of it >> i love your dress >> i splurged a little because liberty mutual customize my car insurance and i saved hundreds that's great. >> i know. right. >> i've been telling everyone >> did you hear that type just set her first word >> can you say mama? >> never? >> can you say on >> how many people did you tell >> only pay for what you need >> like, hey, they're brenda. >> it's carroll exactly. >> so which like are we operating on? >> you mean arm?

>> it's all connected asking the right question, can greatly impact your future. >> you sure you're an orthopedist. >> actually, i'm a sagittarius specially when it comes to your finances, give a question. >> are us certified financial planner? >> yes. i'm a cfp professional >> cop professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. that's why it's got to be a cfb bind. your cfp professional, and let's make a plan doubt work. >> so when you think about these were to take everything down to this duck from design and products to removal and installation, turned down amazing about this with you through every step of your through every step of your remodel the from chavez and huerta to striking janitors in the 90s to today's fast-food workers. californians have led the way. now, $20/hour is here. thanks to governor newsom and leaders in sacramento, we can lift workers out of poverty. stop the race to the bottom in the fast-food industry. and build a california for all of us. thank you governor and our california lawmakers for fighting for what matters.

business. and our california lawmakers it's not a nine-to-five proposition. it's all day and into the night. it's all the things that keep this world turning. the go-tos that keep us going. the places we cheer. and check in. they all choose the advanced network solutions and round the clock partnership from comcast business. see why comcast business powers more small businesses than anyone else. get started for $49.99 a month plus ask how to get up to an $800 prepaid card. don't wait- call today. limited time the source with kaitlan collins. next >> tonight, just released bodycam video is revealing new details about a fatal police involved shooting in chicago, 26 year-old dexter reed was killed during a traffic stop last month involving five police officers, nearly 100 shots were fired towards read raising questions about whether the officers use excessive force cnn's omar jimenez has

that story. we want to warn you some of what you'll see as graphic >> march 21, 2024, chicago police are initiating a traffic stop on a driver reportedly for not wearing a seat belt. according to the civilian office of police accountability a traffic stop being conducted by five tactical officers roll the window down >> what are you doing >> this role that one down too? >> don't roll the window. i'm >> don't roll the window up do not roll the window light the doors >> the temperature quickly escalates. one officer puts what appears to be his gun on the windshield, read then fires first hitting an officer in the forearm according to the initial investigation patient then chaos >> so as far

>> reid goes down >> then three final gunshots >> 96 in total, according to investigators a gun was later recovered from the front seat of reads car, porsche thanks. had just been on the phone with her brother in the minutes before it all happened, then she turned on a police scanner at her shop, listening to the police how can i fan shots by? >> but i can >> hear all the shy photo scanner like i can hear so many sides, so many sides, so many sides? >> but did note that it was >> my brother. so dancer, no.

>> later on in my >> that no size that i heard and then emily ems going past my shop it was my brother was the most heartbreaking thing i've ever felt my life. >> one of the families attorneys argues this never should have happened in the first place. >> there was a weapon recovered in his car. however, it started with an unconstitutional pretextual and unnecessary stop of dexter reed and that's what precipitated the entire incident and questions remain over why tactical officers initiated the traffic stop for a supposed seat belt violation as part of a brief statement, chicago police says this incident is still under investigation, but stop is where it all began. >> computable. stop. my nephew. he'll be a lab today, >> reads uncle sitting alongside his father when this happened to my nephew i hope the police can understand that this is the same pain that they feel when an officer is killed

in the line of duty. >> it's a pain that manifest in memories. and pain that manifests in despair >> get that no. i don't know what and i just wish that i could tell hill. well but to see him gunned down, i never ever thought that it'd be whom >> i know thought that it would be hill i've never thought that it would be him. >> now, the chicago police department says is still under investigation and the civilian office of police accountability says they've recommended the police superintendent that they relieve four of these officers of their policing powers as that investigation continues, the cook county state's attorney here says they are investigating for a potential criminal prosecution, but they are not there at this point. and look as people watch this and react to this. reed did fire his weapon first and so that initial response from