sample of the abuses of human rights and environmental injustices on heard voices, luxury, to be honest, people, i know for russia, they're like any other people from any other country. we want to leave freely connect with our community and tap into conversations you will find elsewhere. we have to be able to educate ourselves to be able to identify what is freedom and what is enough to stream on algebra from the united nations security council. agree on a resolution calling for cease fire and don't say it's rejected. the latest text drafted by the us, other members will present a new one. but how lot easy to pos, and if it does, how would it be in force? this is inside stored, the hello that on james bay's, the un security council has failed to pos us drafted resolution. recognizing the

need for sees foreign goss. it was the 1st time the americans would use such strong language, but it wasn't enough for russia, china and algeria, they rejected the tax because it didn't. the mom, the new agency saw because it tied any pools in a still, it has to the release of all is riley captives. the vote mocks, the councils latest failure to take action since, as well as war ongoing. so it began over 6 months ago and it wouldn't be the last vote. another draft is due to be titled a monday this time with stronger language. but kind of council members overcome their entrenched positions and internal politics to reach an agreement. and even if the resolution is possible, israel take notice we'll explore all these issues with a panel of guests in a moment. but 1st, this report from alexandra buys. once again, the human body responsible for ensuring international peace and security blocks from taking action by language and politics. those against on friday,

russia and china, vito, a us drafted security council resolution that finally acknowledged the importance of a ceasefire and gaza. the text was significantly stronger than anything previously tabled by the americans, but it still fell short of demanding an immediate cease, fire, and tide. any pause in fighting to the release of all is rarely kept its russell called the text hypocritical, and criticized it for not holding israel accountable attributed to him on the web post. i wish to draw attention to the following. the us draft contains an effective green light for israel to mount a military operation in rough or at the very least the ult this try to make it such that nothing you would prevent weston jerusalem from continuing the brutal cleansing of the south of the gaza strip through you guys out, china accuse the us of dodging the most important issue. we will move well this weekend to wash your good and if the us the serious about to cease fire,

then please vote in favor of the other draft resolution. clearly calling for a ceasefire. do us ambassador said the veto with cynical and petty rushing. china simply did not want to vote for resolution that was penned by the united states because they would rather see us fail then to see this counsel succeed. think washington is israel's closest ally and has blocked 3 previous attempts to call for a ceasefire. i'll jerry's ambassador, the security council's only error member, reminded his colleagues that if they had passed those earlier resolutions, thousands of lives could have been saved. 6 months into israel's war, more than 32000 palestinians, mostly women and children have been killed, frustrated by inaction. a majority of the non permanent members have drafted a separate resolution that demands an immediate and unconditional ceasefire. and another vote is due to be held in the coming days. they agree

a ceasefire is long overdue. but the question remains whether anything can be done to overcome the politics of the court. the un security council meeting. so john alexandra buyers out a 0 for inside story. let's bring it to a panel of guests to discuss this further. joining us from maryland is francis j. ricardo and e, a former us ambassador to egypt and took here in colorado, who's saying hardy, he's a former injection assistant for minnesota and full, but i'm positive. and in ramallah, hannon, ash raleigh, a former member of the policy he likes to the counselor she previously served on the executive committee of the pillow. a very distinguished panel, thank you very much for joining us. so the un security council vote 11 votes in favor of us draft, right? the resolution 3 against china and russia double because that's why it didn't go through. and algeria significantly, the arab member of the security council,

one extension guy on hold on. can i ask you, your reaction is the policy and member of the panel to the security council. once again, failing to reach agreement on the gospel again, the u. s. effective, and if you're late this month to lots of other institutions and other to try to pass the notion of money in cindy or if you want or, or a way in which i can pass on. so just as a sounds without having any substance, so that also to the acura about this and the that there's many different genius without in any way trying to address related issues. first as managers to tie to, to condemn how much in every possible way headlines and other organizations and make sure that it's on record. and of course the 3 integrates that q patients. so come us as long as they are in fact us. and then as the again talks about the,

the, the under well as though that is investigation and it should be investigative but their obligation that the members of underwent, took part and be october the 2nd attack. i'm sean without my, my creating impressions like that. and it's even manage it to at the back of the house is that isn't a single dimension as then what kind of as, as genocide, a vision is kind of against too many to of it's been ongoing use of hunger, food, and medicine and so on. as instruments of war, and it just somehow is a passive voice. all the, all the humanitarian disaster, all the stomach. i mean, it's conflict induced. and somehow the conflict is between what tool does one mention of palestinians, but everything else is about how much. and then package to the conflict and all the suffering induced by the conflict. so it made the, the issue at times to examine that

a says run completely and puts on record all the and i get this thing pertaining to whether this is how much another group. so the, and why relegation or does that even the hosting does not address the issue that it does is there that is responsible for blocking the trusting punch blocking before that fits service. and on the other materials from coming through, does it have a 2 pallet stay? and it is actually is then that the bombing and selling and killing and block that exist on the field. and it's been ongoing, is doing that constantly. so what do you as wants to have poor to come in and so that's the, is there any kind of get into that one day, i'd rather spend the different ways to die in guys and certainly isn't and has always possible. and that's why we find these as a notions, as always, when the adapted by the u. s. using and base of tactics,

avoiding issues and condemning the different boxes were about to be condemning, as well as the major source of investing. but in congress of what's happening, that's why i think the, the vi to in this case was what it is a. because this directly the u. s. would in a sense, manipulate any other solutions and then try to load them and make them meaningless in order to upsetting. but as you saw 548 meters a, an order to ensure it has impunity. 48 meters against any kind of it is a no show that to a ton visible a comfortable. and this is that cuz this is the context within which we have to address the american manipulation of the month to lesser institutions as no. well, a pretty dining verdicts on, on what happens and, and that resolution from you that you are all veterans of international diplomacy. and you know that in un security council resolutions,

the precision of language is very important to have the resolution here. so you might be with me just reading the exact words of the t power golf, which said the security council determines the imperative of an immediate and sustained c spot to protect civilians on all sides. and to will that hand on the equipment to the supports, ongoing international diplomatic efforts to secure such as the spot in connection with the release of old remaining hostages. frances, they change that language in the last 48 hours and secondly, blinked, and it was already traveling. and the region was already in colorado said that shows the us is pushing for a c spa. all the said it was very deliberately, i'm big us using the what determines the imperative of the see strong rob, the moms as the spa. i'm directly linking it to the release of those being held captive in goal. so what do you say to that process? first of all, a i accept the criticisms that the doctor shall we levels just one of the most

admired or the palestinian leaders police in the united states. and i think there's only 9, there was a lot of arch and what talked restaurant we called acrobatics that it's striking in the language. however, i see the substance of it is very, very clear. it would have been very helpful. i think 2 american and other diplomatic efforts, the country and the objection of efforts i'll be interested in baset of how reduced you had the past had at least the russians. and the chinese abstained and had an explanation that could well have criticized it in their exclamation for explanation of vote along the lines that dr. sharp pointed out, not going far enough, etc. but the underlying and all that. i think it would have helped the diplomacy that is ongoing and i think it would have helped in the long around the

israelis would have shaded. these really right would have hated it is really a piece cam such of it as may be left a might well welcome to, i don't know. there isn't much left to that piece camp under the current circumstances. but in discrediting the is rarely rejection, is of a 2 state solution of the, of the power steering and identity of the palace, city and state. uh, as long with rejecting and condemning the to the rejection is on the palette sitting side. how much not like, i think it would have set the grounds for some substantial diplomatic advancement. and then if you put into that, that the russians and chinese, at least epstein what a powerful backing that would have been and by law doing it with all of this language. the doctor sharp pointed out, was in a way, in a backhanded way erecting this. rarely excuse is this really right when just really

piece cap rejection as a reckoning her excuses to knock them down. it had that resolution past, so i would have seen it as a very useful outcome. and for the 1st time united states back in, even if in an artful way, less direct way than i would have, like perhaps a call for a ceasefire, a, a initial ceasefire deliberately explicitly to lead to a permanent one. i was, i thought that would have been useful your view, well not who signed? because if it is linked to the release of those being held captive in ga. so there are folks going on in dow hall, but they could take weeks, they might not go anywhere. and then that means the reason i say as far as the, when i guess the uh, the top priority. now for all of the members of the security council, including the united states, as well as the but his thing and,

and the out of states is to have an immediate cease fire in, in, in the us. so this human disaster, let's come to, to an end to and if i discussed the solution that the united states submitted the yesterday before the security and johnson, i would, i would, uh analyze it in terms of the successive attempts on the parts of the security of co counsel from october 7th, 2012 to city city yesterday to adopt a solution for and for these 5, the wording of the draft. the resolution yesterday from an american thought of you, i guess, was in a box or it was cost effective in the sense this is the 1st time that the united states before the security council corps for an immediate and sustainable

ceasefire. so this is something that we could have both of them understand some uh it is that the nation's that's where i, that's it headed by dr. ash raleigh or by the representatives of russia and china before the concert yesterday. and i would have preferred from a diploma. i think part of you and the conservation, the interest of the innocent civilians by this thing is in the gus that invest though for trying to obtain live deanna did. yesterday. the drafters illusion submitted by the united states yesterday gardner's 11 votes of support. the 14 allowed to 15 members on the gospel. so this is something in maturity that we have to take into account the only, aside from the to vito's, exact size by china and russia,

the only uh position to that process. it was on being from, from, from juliet the, on the i to member state on the concert. so i, i think that yesterday was another reflection of g as in the national geo politics and its impact on the workings and the effectiveness of the security council dealing with the situations that undermine that undermine the national and these, and front end security on the all not points on if i, if i could bring in on, on the, on that point the us on boss of the said that she felt that this was the reasons that by rusher and trying to write things they did was deeply, deeply cynical. so one of the reasons is they would never vote for anything drawing up by the us. you agree with what china and russia did? yes, today, but do you agree with her that this is all infected by the big 2 political divides

in the world right now? a look at very clearly that manipulation of this month, the lateral body has always been carried out by the us. i told you where at for, to meet or when it comes to events have been exercised by the u. s. a. manipulation of the language of this course. eviction of any kind of resolution has always been by the us. so let's not, not start talking about china and the shots and the decided thing or the employee and all sorts of metrics in order to prevent resolutions, not that talk. now the u. s. conduct immediately put an end to the war 2 that came into the slot, the genocide by just not providing isn't done with the weapons and with the findings and with my daughter a blank check in on that to kathy, i'll talk to his lunch. is good. that immediately go to the food into guys, up by the, through the land clustering points by bringing in her hands to open. that's i have

cut them up with some of them that are trusting points that go down built in the food and prevented the started ration, but they use of food on medicine and supplies as a means of killing people. lots of things, the u. s. good them. instead, it's managed to a boat to be to 7 or the previous was your lucian, one after the other, the in order to buy as many times in order to avoid any kind of resolution that would in any way and be, is that genocide done that on page, and that is to blame, others like the sizing, the situation, the u. s. has always used for you and was own, it should be in order to maintain it says impunity and under to the what is that and that's been part of the show conflicted with relationship and we've, it's been said then ultimately that's the u. s. will never allow and it is a notion took, it has decided then openly or to use. and these sanctions against us let us know

the language. it does not mention as then as we say, and i make that is something called map in a little mature, which is the equivalent of the passive voice. in english. the unknown type of choice are the only known people mentioned. and this is a notion of how much than others, the organizations that etc, etc, whatever. and of course, and why, of having to investigate and accept the independent new to investigation. and of course, the hosting, but it comes out to, you know, a perfectly innocence and so it has nothing to do with this. everybody else is going to them. and it does everybody else's responsibility on all. the fact is, most of like my international law and international humanitarian law, even the palestinian people are dimensions on the watson and the lot is the most

true about the vision of a 2 state solution, which is fine by line good when they are now in trying to destroy the city and state and to, to carry out genocide an ethnic cleansing and metric has been published. i mean, this is this in 10 years. and i think if we start tag to start to pick this thing, do that this might work and we can use the for the 1st time they mentioned these 5, no mention teach 5 and before, but they manage to ensure that that is language that the records in the add ons are rest multilateral organization that's would not in any way condemn exams, that would be something that is the, come on, let's crime. and on the contrary, that was put on that kind of thing, is that, that not even proven about what the, what time i showed others didn't or even the the and what i'm showing. so i really like to touch on that the ration. yeah. let me, let me bring in front, says now if i can, francis, all the spotlights is on the us,

some basta to the united nations, linda thomas greenfield. you, i know we've had postings to 4 different countries as a us on boss of the, you know, the pressure is but she must be under a great deal of pressure here. and i just wanna bring in a little bit of my own reporting cuz i've been based at the u. n. for the last 11 years for i, which is 0. and i've had a number of conversations with her in recent months. and with me, she sticks to the official us line, but i've been told by a number of senior security council diplomats that she's increasingly uncomfortable in her role and uncomfortable with her countries policy. and yet she's the one who has to stick a hand up in vito if those, if that reporting is correct and i can only tell you that's what people are telling me. how difficult must that be. it certainly is difficult, but she is a professionals professional and she has a, a, an oath of office and a deep professional and personal loyalties to her office and her responsibilities

under the constitution. but this question leads to a follow up with dr. i. sure i, we said she so wonderfully articulated, the palestinian, the outside, the palestinian sense of injustice over many years. and many americans, not just american diplomats who were concerned in the region under more than understand that i sympathized with it. we've seen it. we've witnessed it the treatment that help. oh, that is all i, i one can't set it aside. it is there. on the is rarely size there's, there's that there was deep sentiments and, and feelings. i don't mean to equate them. that's not the point. when you're a practitioner and you're trying to find a way forward, you often have to, in some way show back it but dispassionately. they're very offensive things that you find in the language of a resolution or something and see what you can get that. ready take you forward to

the, the larger goal in this case. uh, i think the, these really have created this really right, because really is a good mix to use is rarely piece rejection. as the goal is to explicitly have supported come off in order to support a 2 state solution, they have committed to his store and blunder in doing what they have done in gaza. most of the world now, which before i will speak of the western world, at least, and in the united states, there's a reason why the united states relentlessly has vetoed a resolution center unusual. that's because of popular sympathies and understanding, even it's misplaced for to the right present much as it is rarely stage point of view. but the, the is really right wing cap and less understanding from what the palestinians have experienced under occupation all this time. this is historic,

strategic belonged or, or the new ton yahoo! lead is rarely state in in committee what the most of the world now the western world is explicitly stating as a criminal acts under international law. and perhaps even under us law. look at what senator schumer said, the other day he didn't call per ceasefire. you could criticize what he said. forget it's not going far enough. but he made a historic speech reflecting a historic change, i believe in american and western world public opinion. these really have watched it from that time. yahoo government has thrown away. it's what it has, what israel has accomplished over generations and getting the sympathy of the world and portraying the palestinians as doctor char, your said is as some kind of you know, terrorist terrorist,

terrorist painting them with a broad brushes as, as if. busy palestinians or the p l o r or terrace. okay, that has been problems is for process. i'd like to take us because we don't have much on fact to the security council because this resolution didn't pause, but there was another one coming up on monday to make sure it's a resolution and this one to mom. so let me just see spot for the month of ramadan, respected by all parties leading to a permanent sustainable cx 5. this is proposed by 8 of the permanent members already china, russia, i'm from say they'll support it. so they have the votes saying this means it's down to the us, will the us be type this or not? given secretary blinking was talking out the idea of the see saw and the us supported the cease fire and that all those say he was those comments were a bit of spin, but they were in the top position. now i think the vote for that resolution. what do you think co sign, and i hope that the security and cancer would come to

a consensus on the need on the immediate need of adopting it as an ocean cooling for any media to and sustain sustainable ceasefire in augusta. and i hope that all the members on the concert, whether permanent members or non permanent members will put domestic. but it takes us side and cost on to aid that efforts. and the initiatives on bringing to and the so that he aggression against the palestinians in in garza, this is from my person. i'm fond of you is the most immediate task now. uh, if we keep going, uh, if we keep using each other, then uh then uh i, i'm afraid that security person would fail at to a tenant, the palestinians. we need. okay. i want to bring in hold on for them for the last

couple, k is right. if i could bring in a non for the last for the last comments on this, if the us supports this resolution, orb stains does not really mean. and the thing will, is ro comply or what sort of pressure is needed from, from washington briefly if you can, it has never complied with any of the ocean name. one of the notion that isn't that it has implemented a single one. so let's, let's not think that we can expect something out of this monday. there's an ocean, get something out there, but this and the latest, there's a notion that is to be presented. it's very clear and very touching fabric type. it means that you card, which is what me and, but i'm the ones i've been saying and that sort of, i guess we're saying that there was, that is a see change in public opinion people. i'm seeing the hunters that i've taken place by is the number of clear on what is going to be in plain sight. it's janice i and now this is a solution to construct an immediate cease fire and doesn't gone over the place in

order to exonerate this drug condemned that. and this is the important thing the u . s. good that done this before they last good. that the same course of thousands of on demand liars, and even from day one they could that said ok, let's set it all for own in terms of exchange of businesses, not everything is dependent on the the hostages. that's where the objectives and october 7th, we have over 9100 understanding in prison. and so i often just my interest is then hold. all of the guys that hosted the hotel has been, and people, even though it's back in the center. let's find some sort of actions i would say is willing to comply with international know that, that it's, but it did a between the side. and of course in terms of the law, the, there's no objective parity. and the u. s. should at least one vote flooded is the

motion that is simple and straightforward and that says, we must save large. now the last time i took a phase of damage, thanks very much to our distinguished panel of gas today. francis j. recall, do you have any who's saying hardy, on how to the actual raleigh extensive coverage of the war on gauze? it continues around the talking out to 0 and you can find more context analysis on our website. i'll just say we're adult calm. we'd like to hear your views on today's discussion. go to our facebook page, that's facebook dot com, forward slash ha inside story. we also want any thoughts you have on what we should discuss next time. you'll find this on x 2, that's at a j inside story for me, james, based on the whole team here in doha, stay safe. i'll see you goes by the latest news as it breaks demonstrators, law ser remaining is really captive brought back from gaza and they want the broad

back now with the 2 coverage posting and save that whatever we did here in his final words, free power stuff made them feel sense and for that he was saying before going from the home to the story, at least 9000 posted in families are missing at least one loved one. at the start table, the a, a c o knows they load balancing from the parallel processing. and so do it's why we work with bill cuz who make it their business to know your business. yep. we all, we, you, oh, why have american evangelicals become his real strongest back? or is us president, you'll find the right to stand with this real with no red line. as long as us support continues, is there anything that can stop is real, solve on concept, from going on in? definitely a quizzical look at us politics. the bottom line,

the showcase of the best documentary pounds from across the name. on the 0, the the top of that on the clock, this is, it needs a life window coming up the next 60 minutes. we will identify and punish everyone who is behind this terrorist attack. vowing revenge the russian president declares a day of national mourning. the death toll from an attack on a constant hole in moscow rises to 100 and such as the tree and is really a type talk is people waiting for rate and goes or 72 pallets the.